The Impact of Stannis and Renly's Starvation at Storm's End on Westeros

In the world of A Song of Ice and Fire, the deaths of Stannis and Renly Baratheon at Storm's End during Robert's Rebellion would have significant implications for the political landscape of Westeros. This scenario would dramatically alter the balance of power and potentially result in profound changes affecting every aspect of the realm.

Lack of Baratheon Unity

Both Stannis and Renly were key figures in the rebellion against King Joffrey Baratheon. Their deaths would have removed two of the main claimants to the Iron Throne, thereby weakening the Baratheon family's position. Robert Baratheon, now the sole surviving Baratheon brother, would have had to rely more heavily on his allies such as Eddard Stark and Jon Arryn. This shift in dynamics would have significant consequences for the stability and unity of the Baratheon cause.

Impact on Robert's Rule

Robert Baratheon's kingship would have faced greater instability without the support of his brothers. Stannis, known for his strong sense of duty and loyalty, might have provided a much-needed stabilizing force to the realm. His absence could have led to more challenges to Robert's authority, particularly from ambitious nobles. Powerful lords like Tywin Lannister, who were already eying the throne, might have capitalized on Robert's weakened position to mount their own claims.

Rise of Other Houses

The deaths of Stannis and Renly would have created a significant power vacuum in the realm. House Targaryen, for instance, could have rallied around Viserys and Daenerys as they sought to reassert their claim to the Iron Throne. Similarly, the Lannisters and the Tyrells might have taken advantage of this opportunity to advance their own interests. The Lannisters, who were already aligned with Robert, would have had a stronger position if Robert were more isolated, while the Tyrells, powerful in the Reach, could have seen Stannis's demise as an opening to expand their influence.

Potential for Civil War

The absence of Stannis and Renly might have led to a different kind of civil strife. Robert’s inability to consolidate power could have led to the emergence of rival factions within the realm. These factions might have begun to challenge Robert's authority, leading to a new war for the throne. The death of Stannis and Renly would have created a fragmented political landscape, making it increasingly difficult for any single ruler to maintain control over the Seven Kingdoms.

Targaryen Resurgence

Without the Baratheon brothers, the Targaryens, particularly Viserys and Daenerys, might have had a better chance of rallying support for their claim to the throne. The Lannisters, who had previously allied with the Baratheons, might have seen Stannis's demise as a chance to become the dominant house in Westeros. However, the Tyrells and other small council members could have also aligned with the Targaryens if they believed that their support could lead to a more stable and favorable political environment.

Different Character Arcs

The narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire would shift dramatically in this scenario. Key characters such as Melisandre, Davos Seaworth, and others who were closely tied to Stannis would have had different paths. For instance, Melisandre, a powerful and mysterious character, might have sought to strengthen her influence without Stannis as a hindrance. Davos, who was fiercely loyal to Stannis, would have had to navigate a new political landscape without his friend and protector.

In summary, the deaths of Stannis and Renly at Storm's End would have likely led to a more fragmented Westeros with power struggles and shifting alliances shaping the future of the realm in unpredictable ways. The political landscape would have been dramatically altered, and the narrative of the story would have taken a different path, with each character facing new challenges and opportunities.