Would Stannis, Benjen, or Tywin Be Crowned After Robert’s Rebellion?

In the complex and tumultuous world of A Song of Ice and Fire by George R.R. Martin, the randomness of events and the shifting loyalties make predicting the future of the Iron Throne a daunting task. If key figures like Jon Arryn, Ned Stark, Robert Baratheon, and Hoster Tully died during Robert's Rebellion, yet the rebels still managed to defeat Rhaegar Targaryen, who would ascend to the throne? Would Stannis Baratheon, Benjen Stark, or Tywin Lannister rule the Seven Kingdoms? Here's an in-depth analysis of the possibilities.

The Allegiances and Loyalists

When considering the rightful successors to the Iron Throne, it's important to revisit the historical context of A Song of Ice and Fire. Robert Baratheon's rebellion succeeded because he had a legitimate claim to the throne through his grandmother, Lady Lyanna Stark, who was the sister of Ned Stark's father. This connection to the Targaryen bloodline was crucial for his revolution to gain legitimacy.

Stannis Baratheon: The Legacy Seeker

The most significant contender for the crown is Stannis Baratheon. As the brother of late King Robert, Stannis has a stronger claim to the Iron Throne than Benjen Stark because of their familial bond. Furthermore, Stannis has inherited the Targaryen bloodline, making him a legitimate claimant. However, his lack of popularity and the small number of followers he commands might pose a challenge. The Books and TV series, however, paint a picture of a leader who doesn't enjoy the same level of adoration as his brother or other powerful characters. His claim to the throne remains valid, but his political support may lag behind.

Benjen Stark: The Young and Unproven Claimant

Benjen Stark, who is the older brother to Jon Snow, would be a less likely candidate. He has no real claim to the throne as he was still very young during the rebellion and had not participated in it in a significant capacity. Though he represents the Stark legacy, his youth and lack of involvement in the rebellion make him an unlikely contender. Additionally, he would face strong competition from much more experienced and established claimants.

Tywin Lannister: Auspicious but Unlikely

Tywin Lannister, the Hand of the King to the late King Robert, also held a strong claim to the throne. However, he has no real familial connection to the Targaryen bloodline, which is a legal requirement for any claimant. Tywin's political ambitions and previous role as the Hand of the King mean he would be a formidable figure, but his lack of a Targaryen connection makes him improbable as the rightful ruler of Westeros. His power and influence, however, would certainly make him a contender for a regent position.

The Alternative: Viserys Targaryen

Another possibility, though less likely due to the strong support for Stannis, is the return of King Viserys Targaryen to Westeros. If Stannis were not popular enough or didn't gain enough support, the old claimant to the throne might re emerge as a unifying figure. The plan of inviting Viserys back to Westeros and installing Stannis as Lord Protector and Hand of the King is an interesting one. This would provide stability and the legitimacy of a direct bloodline to the Targaryen line, potentially averted the chaos of the War of the Five Kings.

The Aftermath: A Potential War of Succession

No matter the outcome, the blood and ambition of Westerosi aristocracy would lead to a series of battles and negotiations. Assuming Stannis wins, the return of a Targaryen claimant like Viserys could spark another war, much like the War of the Five Kings. The loyalty of Stannis's forces to him could wane if he doesn't take swift and decisive actions.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Succession

In the intricate political landscape of Westeros, the question of who would rule the Seven Kingdoms after Robert's Rebellion remains complex. Stannis Baratheon, with his Targaryen bloodline and fraternal tie to Robert, is likely the most prominent contender. However, the support of his political allies and his ability to command respect among the warring factions will determine his success. Regardless of the outcome, the story of Westeros is a testament to the complications of royal succession, making the realm a place of constant political intrigue.