Gandalf and Thorin's Relationship After The Hobbit: A Glimpse Through Literature and Cinema

Introduction

The relationship between Gandalf and Thorin Oakenshield is a fascinating one, especially in the context of J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit and the subsequent cinematic adaptations by Peter Jackson. While the story of these Hobbiton heroes is celebrated, the aftermath of their journey to reclaim the Lonely Mountain (Erebor) is often shrouded in mystery and uncertainty. Here, we explore how their relationship changes (or doesn't change) after the events of The Hobbit, drawing insights from both the book and the films.

Book vs. Movie Observations

“The Hobbit” Book

In the The Hobbit novel, much of the narrative revolves around the quest of the company to reclaim Erebor from Smaug. Gandalf plays a crucial role as a mentor, advisor, and protector throughout their journey. However, the book does not delve deeply into the relationship dynamics between Gandalf and Thorin after the climax of the story, which is marked by Thorin's death during the Battle of Five Armies. According to the novel, Gandalf mourns the passing of Thorin and the loss of the royal family of Erebor, including their heirs.

At the Battle of Five Armies, Thorin is killed, and both his heir and Dain Ironbeard's son who might have succeeded him also perish. The absence of a clear successor and the tragic loss of a revered leader leave a profound void in Erebor's society. Gandalf, while feeling the weight of this loss, finds himself bereft of a companion and friend. In the book, there is no clear indication of how Gandalf's personal relationship with Thorin evolves, if at all. The novel largely focuses on the epic tale of the battle and the subsequent events, leaving the reader to wonder about the inner turmoil faced by the characters.

2012-2014 “The Hobbit” Movie Trilogy

Adapting from the book, Peter Jackson's film series adds a more dramatic and emotional layer to Thorin's relationship with Gandalf. The movie series, while filling in the gaps, still ends with a similar outcome: Thorin is killed during the Battle of Five Armies, along with his heirs. However, the movies provide a more elaborate portrayal of the characters' emotions, relationships, and internal conflicts.

In the films, Gandalf's relationship with Thorin is more nuanced. The movies highlight the growing bond between them, a relationship that is further strained and ultimately redefined by Thorin's ambitions and his human-like personality. Additionally, the movies give a glimpse into the political turmoil and the clan's struggles after the battle, showing that just like in the book, there is no "after the events of The Hobbit" in terms of their direct working relationship.

Making a strong case for the depth of their relationship, visual and narrative techniques in the films accentuate the contrast between Gandalf's wisdom and Thorin's stubborn pride. The films also emphasize the loss and the sense of desolation felt by Gandalf and the other characters, emphasizing the cultural and emotional gravity of the moment.

Regret and Beyond

Regret in Both

While it is clear that Gandalf mourns the loss of Thorin and his heirs, both the book and the movies suggest that there is little opportunity for the relationship to change or continue in the way they had intended. The sense of loss is palpable, especially from Gandalf's perspective. His journey from mentor to a figure who loses a cherished friend is a poignant one. In the books and movies, Gandalf is shown to be deeply affected by the loss and the changes in the geopolitical landscape of Middle-earth, but there is no indication of a coming together or an evolution of their relationship.

It is important to note that while Gandalf plays an essential role throughout the events of The Hobbit, the story's culmination in both the book and the films marks a definitive end to their working relationship. Gandalf's regret and the unspoken chord of sadness are woven throughout the narrative, serving as a backdrop to the broader story of Middle-earth.

Reading and Watching Recommendations

Reading the Book First

For those inclined towards a more intimate and detailed reading experience, it is highly recommended to start with the book. J.R.R. Tolkien's prose provides deeper insight into the character dynamics and a more profound understanding of Middle-earth's lore. Peter Jackson's films, with their visual and narrative richness, can offer a different angle to the story but might not capture all the subtleties of the book.

Indulging in Both

However, for a comprehensive experience, reading the book and watching the movies in tandem can be a delightful choice. Each medium brings forth its unique strengths, and combining the two can offer a richer understanding of the characters and the world of Middle-earth. While the books provide a more textured experience, the films, with their cinematic techniques, can make the narrative more engaging and visually appealing.

Ultimately, both mediums offer valuable insights and can contribute to a well-rounded appreciation of The Hobbit and its characters. Regardless of one's preferred medium, the story of Thorin and Gandalf remains a poignant examination of companionship and loss in a fantastical world.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Gandalf's relationship with Thorin may remain unaltered in the aftermath of the events of The Hobbit, both the book and the movies effectively convey the profound and incomparable bond between them. The sense of loss, regret, and the enduring legacy of the royal family of Erebor are key themes that are explored in both mediums. Whether through prose or visual storytelling, the impact of these characters on the narrative and the broader world of Middle-earth is undeniable.

In the end, the memories of Thorin and his heirs serve as a reminder of the importance of friendship and the transient nature of life. Gandalf, having witnessed the rise and fall of a kingdom, is left to grapple with the implications of their journey. While the relationship may not evolve, the legacy they leave behind continues to shape the land and its inhabitants.

Keywords

Gandalf, Thorin, The Hobbit, Erebor, Book and Movie Differences