Would Gandalf Return to a Hero’s Welcome in Valinor?

Questions about Gandalf's ultimate destiny in Valinor often arise, especially after his pivotal role in defeating Sauron and helping the Free Peoples of Middle-earth. Would he receive a hero's welcome, and would his name revert to Olorin?

The Many Names of Gandalf

If we consider Gandalf as Olórin, it was merely another of his names, much like how Aragorn had many names. Olórin was just one of the many identities Gandalf wore.

Would Gandalf be able to return to the state of a full Maia, with all the powers and privileges that come with that rank? Absolutely, and for good reason. Unlike Saruman, Gandalf completed his quest without wavering. After his mission, Gandalf would once again be free from the need for a physical incarnation, transforming back into a spirit being like the Istars of old.

Fana and Flexibility

One of the blessings of being a Maia would be the ability to have a fana. A fana is a 'body' that can be put on and off like clothing, allowing Gandalf to assume any form he wishes. This might make Gandalf more inclined to use his name 'Gandalf' and his appearance, especially when with friends like Bilbo, Frodo, and later, Sam.

I imagine Gandalf using his name and appearance, particularly when interacting with these beloved characters. Even with the arrival of Legolas and Gimli, Gandalf might retain his name and form as fond memories of his time in Middle-earth.

Retirement to the Blessed Realms

It’s possible that Gandalf would return to the Blessed Realms, or perhaps choose to do so after the deaths of Sam and Frodo. The arthritic knees would no longer be a hindrance, and Gandalf might miss smoking. However, his presence in Valinor would be much more serene, as he would no longer need to traverse the physical world.

Songs and Legends

The names and memory of Gandalf in Middle-earth would live on in songs and stories. Elves would sing of his deeds, and those who knew him would refer to him with affection. However, in Valinor, Tolkien's description of Gandalf is that of a dreamweaver in Lórien, weaving dreams and smoking his pipe. His residence would likely be in the Gardens of Lórien, his pipe smoke lingering in the magical atmosphere, a reminder of his adventures and destiny.

Identity and Influence

Deciding whether Gandalf would return to Olorin is a complex question. If all of the future was foreseen in Valinor, then Gandalf would merely be fulfilling his predestined path, which would earn him only a pat on the back. However, if we consider the possibility that his role as Gandalf had a significant influence on his psyche, he may have retained the name Olorin on his return to Valinor. Yet, he would not be the same being he once was, having experienced an immense range of emotions and interactions with various races.

Ultimately, the answer to whether Gandalf would return to a hero’s welcome in Valinor and retain the name Olorin likely lies in the hands of the reader's interpretation of Tolkien's works.

Would Gandalf’s name change back to Olorin? Would he fully retain his name 'Gandalf'? The answer may be found in the rich tapestry of Tolkien's imagination and the enduring legacy of this beloved character.