Why Some Readers Prefer Canon Characters Over Original Characters in Fanfiction

It is not uncommon for fans to develop strong preferences for certain types of stories within the vast world of fanfiction. Some find reading fanfiction to be a journey of exploration for pre-existing characters and worlds. For others, however, the inclusion of original characters (OCs) can detract from their enjoyment of the narrative. This article delves into why some readers prefer stories centered around established characters from canon, rather than those featuring original characters (OCs).

Common Preferences Among Fanfiction Readers

Many readers have specific preferences when it comes to fanfiction, and it is not unusual for fans to prefer stories that revolve around established characters rather than original characters. The primary reason for this preference is often frustration with OC-centric stories where the original characters they love are sidelined or altered in ways that feel forced.

For some, the presence of OCs in a story can feel like a distraction from the original narrative and the characters they enjoy. This can be particularly frustrating when the OC takes a central role or alters the dynamics of the relationship or storyline in a way that feels incongruent with the original work. Readers may seek stories that focus more on the characters they love, ensuring a richer and more authentic reading experience.

Limitations of OCs in Fanfiction

The inclusion of original characters (OCs) in fanfiction can have advantages, but it also comes with challenges. While some OCs are used as side characters to drive the plot forward or expand the world, others can detract from the experience if they are made into main characters or if they feel out of place within the original story.

Real Issues with OCs: Many readers, like the author, find OC-centric stories to be frustrating. OCs are often portrayed as self-inserts, extremely idealized, and one-dimensional. These characters can overshadow the beloved canon characters, making the experience less enjoyable. Realistically, a balance is needed to ensure that the OC is a positive addition to the story and strengthens the narrative rather than detracts from it.

Types of OC Fanfiction that are Acceptable

While there are common complaints, not all OC-centric fanfiction is bad. Certain OCs, particularly side characters, can be used effectively to enhance the story. Here are some guidelines for acceptable OC fanfiction:

Side Characters: Side characters, especially ones used as plot devices, can be a welcome addition. They help move the plot along and provide depth to the world. For example, in a Harry Potter fanfiction, the addition of new members to the Wizengamot can enrich the story without overshadowing the main characters. Canon-Based OCs: Some fanfictions introduce OCs who are deeply rooted in the canon. They fit seamlessly into the world and expand the narrative, almost as if they were part of the original storyline. These OCs are usually well-researched and based on canonical elements, ensuring that they feel authentic and enrich the story without detracting from it.

No fanfic is perfect, but those that carefully integrate OCs in a way that benefits the story and respects the original work can be appreciated by readers who enjoy a mix of familiar and new elements. However, stories that tag as starring an OC but do not deliver on this promise are often skipped by readers who prioritize canonical stories.

Preferences and Core Audience

Although original characters (OCs) are a popular element in fanfiction, they are not always preferred. Many fans want to read stories that focus on established characters. This preference is understandable as they are the characters the fans know and love, creating a deeper connection with the story. While OC fanfiction does have a niche audience, it is not the majority of fans.

Conclusion: The inclusion of original characters (OCs) in fanfiction, while adding variety and depth, should not overshadow the beloved canon characters. Balancing the narrative to ensure that both OCs and canonical characters are well-developed and integrated can lead to a richer reading experience. Readers with specific preferences for canonical stories should seek out fanfiction that adheres to these preferences and offers a fulfilling reading experience.