Why Do People Think Hermione Should Have Been the Main Character in the Harry Potter Series?

The debate over whether Hermione Granger should have been the main character in the Harry Potter series has been a recurring topic among fans. While many argue that Harry Potter's journey is central, others believe Hermione's contributions and character development make her a compelling and deserved protagonist. In this piece, we explore the reasons behind this debate and the reasons why both characters are crucial to the series.

Intelligence and Resourcefulness

Hermione is often celebrated for her exceptional intelligence and resourcefulness. She is a crucial asset to the trio, using her knowledge and skills to solve problems. Many fans admire her logical approach and argue that her character embodies the qualities of a traditional hero in a different way than Harry. Hermione's intelligence serves as a counterbalance to the more action-oriented Harry, providing a more well-rounded narrative perspective.

Character Development

One of the most compelling aspects of Hermione's character is her significant growth throughout the series. Starting as a somewhat anxious and academic student, she evolves into a confident and brave young woman. This journey resonates strongly with many readers, making her development a central theme in the books. Some fans feel that her character development is as compelling, if not more so, than Harry's.

Representation of Feminism

Hermione's character is often highlighted as a strong female role model. In a series that features a predominantly male perspective, her intelligence and strength provide a powerful counterbalance. Her journey as a female protagonist in a male-dominated world adds a layer of depth and significance to the narrative. Some fans advocate for her representation as a more fitting main character in a modern context that values female empowerment.

Team Dynamics

Another key argument is that the success of the trio's adventures relies heavily on the contributions of Hermione and Ron. Many fans believe that the narrative could have explored Hermione's perspective more deeply, showcasing her significant contributions to the group's successes. Hermione's practical skills and emotional support are integral to the group, making her role central to the overall story.

Narrative Choices

Several readers point out that the series sometimes sidelines Hermione in favor of Harry's storyline. This can lead to a perception that her character is underappreciated. Some argue that if Hermione had received the same narrative focus as Harry, her character could have been a more compelling protagonist. This critique highlights how narrative choices can influence character development and fan perspective.

Despite these points, it is important to recognize that Harry Potter's character is essential to the series. Harry's journey as the chosen one provides a unique and necessary plotline that is central to the wizarding world. Both characters contribute significantly to the story, and the debate over who should be considered the main character reflects the richness and depth of Harry Potter's world.

Ultimately, both Harry and Hermione are crucial to the series, and the debate over their roles as central characters speaks to the complexity and appeal of J.K. Rowling's storytelling. Their interactions and mutual growth make the series more engaging and resonate with fans on a deeper level.