What Should an Author Look for When They Read Their Book

Introduction

As authors pour their hearts and souls into the creation of their books, it can be daunting to face the written word in the form of one's own work. This introspective journey of reading and evaluating one's own book is crucial for growth and improvement. In this article, we will explore the aspects an author should examine when reading their book, highlighting both the successes and areas for improvement.

Identify Strengths and Weaknesses

When an author begins to review their book, the first step should be to identify those moments where the text rings true and conveys the intended emotions, themes, and messages effectively. It is essential to recognize which characters, scenes, or concepts are resonating with the reader and why. However, it's equally important to identify where the writing falls short, where the narrative breaks down, and where the readers might lose engagement. This dual focus is crucial in providing a holistic view of the book's quality.

Analyze the Dialogue and Character Development

A significant aspect of any book is the dialogue and character development. Authors should examine each character's dialogue closely, assessing whether it feels authentic and true to that character's personality. Are the lines natural and reflective of the speaker's voice and background? Do the conversations propel the plot forward or merely serve as a means of exposition?

Speaking of plot, the author must also critically evaluate the progression of the story. Is there a clear and compelling arc? Do the events unfold in a way that keeps readers engaged and invested in the outcome? Weak plot elements can seriously undermine the overall quality of the book. By spotting where the story falters, the author can make necessary adjustments to enhance the narrative flow.

Consider the Language and Writing Style

The language used in a book is not just a means of communication; it is a tool for conveying tone, emotion, and style. Authors should scrutinize the language to ensure that it is well-crafted and appropriate for the genre and tone of the book. Are there any awkward phrases or overly complex sentences that detract from the reading experience? Is the prose crisp and engaging, or does it lag and drag the pace of the story?

Additionally, the author should ask if the writing style complements the genre and the intended audience. While experimentation and creativity are encouraged, it's important that the style aligns with the expectations of the genre and the taste of the target audience. Striking the right balance between innovation and convention is critical for a successful book.

Seek External Feedback

One of the most powerful tools an author has in the self-assessment process is the external feedback from trusted peers, beta readers, or an editorial team. Their perspectives can provide valuable insights into aspects of the book that the author may have overlooked. External feedback can highlight areas that might need additional work, remove ambiguity, or achieve clarity. It can also provide a fresh pair of eyes to catch any inconsistencies or errors that might have been missed during the initial draft.

Furthermore, beta readers can offer valuable feedback on the pacing, character development, and overall narrative. Their honest opinions can be instrumental in refining the manuscript and improving the final product.

Use Tools for Analysis

There are various tools and software designed specifically for editing and self-assessment. Grammarly, Hemingway Editor, and Scrivener offer features like grammar and style checks, readability analysis, and even suggestions for improving sentence structure and flow. These tools can highlight issues that the author might miss during a manual review, providing a more objective perspective.

Additionally, some platforms allow authors to share their work temporarily with a small group of beta readers or a writing workshop. This can provide a broad spectrum of feedback, including comments on different aspects of the book, from the plot to the dialogue.

Conclusion

Reading and evaluating one's own book is a crucial process for an author. By identifying the strengths and weaknesses, analyzing dialogue and character development, considering the language and writing style, seeking external feedback, and utilizing tools for analysis, an author can gain valuable insights into the quality of their work. This introspection is not only beneficial for improving the current draft but also for future writing projects. Remember, every author starts with room for improvement, and by acknowledging these areas, authors can grow and refine their craft, ultimately creating better books that resonate with their audience.