The Intricacies of Plot in Middle-earth: Gandalf's Confidentiality and Frodo's Journey

Throughout the rich narrative of The Lord of the Rings, several instances of confidentiality and strategic plots by Gandalf demand closer examination, especially as they pertain to the Ring. Here, we delve into why Gandalf did not reveal all about the One Ring to Bilbo or Frodo, and explore the multifaceted reasons behind Frodo's actions in returning to Bag End before heading to Rivendell with Gandalf. Understanding these nuances is crucial for appreciating the complex interplay of characters and events in J.R.R. Tolkien's world.

Why Did Gandalf Not Inform Bilbo About the Ring?

Gandalf, the wise wizard, did not return the One Ring to Bilbo but received it from him at the moment of Bilbo's passing. Thereafter, Bilbo was never again in possession of the Ring. This decision by Gandalf was a strategic move to protect Bilbo from the corruption that comes with holding such a powerful artifact. If Gandalf had returned the Ring to Bilbo, it would have endangered the elderly hobbit, who might have been tempted by the Ring's power. Furthermore, revealing the full nature of the Ring to Bilbo would have posed a significant risk, considering his age and the potential for his declining health.

Why Did Frodo Return to Bag End Before Leaving for Rivendell?

Frodo's journey to Bag End before leaving for Rivendell with Gandalf was a more personal choice rooted in sentimental and familial ties. He returned to the Shire, rather than specifically to Bag End, out of a sense of home and familiarity. At that time, Frodo was not aware that he would eventually feel the need to travel with Gandalf to the Undying Lands to seek relief from the magical malady. This journey would have great significance in Frodo's later life, but initially, it was just a late decision to return to a place that held familiar warmth and comfort. It reflects Frodo's instinctive desire to return to his roots before setting out on a complex, perilous adventure.

The Role of the One Ring in the Narrative

The One Ring is a central element in The Lord of the Rings, serving as a powerful artifact that corrupts its keepers. Gandalf's decision not to reveal the true nature of the Ring to Bilbo and Frodo was for their protection and to prevent unnecessary danger. Additionally, the destruction of the Ring at the fires of Mount Doom by Gollum symbolizes the end of an era in Middle-earth. By the time Gandalf and the other Ring Bearers left Middle-earth, the Ring had already been destroyed, marking the end of the Third Age.

Elrond and the Council of Rivendell

Elrond, the just and wise leader of Rivendell, was indeed aware of the One Ring. The central question of why Elrond did not reveal more to Frodo is multifaceted. Gandalf had already imparted to Frodo the knowledge necessary, and Frodo was in a deep unconscious state at the time of their arrival in Rivendell. It was Elrond who tended to Frodo, saving his life and ensuring he was in a better state to hear the full story of the Ring. Days after Frodo regained consciousness, Elrond convened the Council of Elrond, where the entirety of the Ring's story and Sauron's ambitions were discussed.

Conclusion

The complex plot of The Lord of the Rings often hinges on strategic secrecy and the careful timing of events. Gandalf's judgments and Elrond's choices are critical in shaping the fate of Middle-earth and its inhabitants. Understanding these nuances enriches the narrative and enhances our appreciation of Tolkien's masterful storytelling.

For a deeper dive into the specific chapters mentioned, read The Lord of the Rings, paying particular attention to A Long-Expected Party, The Shadow of the Past, Many Meetings, and The Council of Elrond in The Fellowship of the Ring.