The Fate of an Orc if They Found the One Ring in LOTR: Speculations and Scenarios

Introduction

The question of what an orc would do if they found the One Ring in The Lord of the Rings (LOTR) is fascinating. Both Sauron and the Ring itself hold immense power and influence over those who come into contact with them. This article explores two possible scenarios based on the lore established in Tolkien's works.

The First Scenario: Word Has Gone Out to Bring Any Rings Directly to Sauron

Let's consider the initial response of an orc upon discovering the One Ring. Orcs, while often depicted as unintelligent, are not entirely devoid of smarts or fear. They would likely recognize the Ring's significance and the potential dangers it poses. An orc would be smart enough or scared enough to bring the Ring to Sauron.

Sauron, the Dark Lord, would eagerly reclaim his "precious." This could lead to widespread chaos and conflict in Middle-earth, as Sauron's return and reestablishment of his power would be met with resistance from various factions. The ensuing struggle for dominance and survival would be relentless and devastating.

The Second Scenario: Word Has Not Gone Out to Bring Any Rings Directly to Sauron

Without any such directive from Sauron, the discovery of the Ring would turn the orcs and trolls into a fight over ownership. This bitter conflict would attract the attention of the Nazg?l, the Ringwraiths, who would intervene to claim the Ring for Sauron.

The fate of the unfortunate orc who picked up the Ring would be similar to that of Gollum, who was eventually subjected to Sauron's will. If the orc were an unassuming one, they might initially use the Ring to remain hidden, much like Gollum in the caves of Mordor. However, the lure of power and the Ring's corrupting influence would eventually overcome them.

After a period of living in hiding, the orc would be tempted to use the Ring for personal gain or revenge. This could lead to their downfall, as the Ring's dark power would cause them to succumb to its influence. Should the Ring slip from their grasp, it might find a new owner, potentially setting off further conflicts and mayhem.

Conclusion: Lessons from Gollum and the Fate of Orcs in Mordor

Orcs, like Gollum, are susceptible to the Ring's power. While an orc in Mordor might be discovered quickly by the Nazg?l or other agents of Sauron, one outside of Mordor would face similar fates to Gollum. The Ring's ability to make its wearer invisible could provide a temporary advantage, but the ultimate consequences would be severe.

The question of latent Ring-resistance in orcs, as well as how they compare to hobbits, adds nuance to our understanding. Some orcs might resist the Ring's call, but their fall is just as inevitable. The story of an orc with the One Ring would be yet another chapter in the ongoing conflict for control of Middle-earth.

There is much to explore in the impact of the One Ring on those who come into contact with it. This scenario is merely a starting point for further contemplation and speculation in the rich and vast world of Middle-earth.