LitLuminaries

Location:HOME > Literature > content

Literature

Smaug and the Lonely Mountain: Myths and Reality

April 04, 2025Literature1112
Smaug and the Lonely Mountain: Myths and Reality Many fans and critic

Smaug and the Lonely Mountain: Myths and Reality

Many fans and critics have argued whether Smaug was truly sealed inside the Lonely Mountain or if he had the freedom to come and go as he pleased. This article delves into the true nature of Smaug's presence in Erebor as depicted in J.R.R. Tolkien's works and the film adaptations of The Hobbit.

The Predetermined Fate of Smaug

Some argue that Smaug's sealing within the Lonely Mountain was a predetermined part of his curse. Smaug, a dragon cursed with an insatiable love for treasure, could not part with his stolen hoard even at the cost of not being able to leave the mountain. This powerful addiction drove him to remain sealed within the Lonely Mountain, a fate that was set for him by his curse (Tolkien, 1937).

Reality Behind the Sealing

Contrary to the above belief, Smaug was not sealed inside the Lonely Mountain. Bilbo Baggins and the dwarves, on the other hand, were more or less confined within the mountain, specifically through the back door they used to enter (Tolkien, 1937; Movie Adaptations).

According to the story, Smaug had the freedom to come and go through the main gate at his will. He could venture out to attack other places, as seen when he attacked Lake-town, leading to the battle that saw Bard become the new Arquebusier of Laketown (Tolkien, 1937; Movie Adaptations). Smaug even left the Lonely Mountain several times to go hunting, showing that he was not confined to the mountain but chose to remain for his precious hoard (Tolkien, 1937).

Death and Aftermath

What can be said about Smaug's final moments is that he was killed by Bard, an arrow piercing the dragon's chest, causing him to fall from the sky onto Lake-town. His body lay in the shallows of Esgaroth for a period of time, marking the tragic end of an age-old tale (Tolkien, 1937; Movie Adaptations).

Conclusion and Analysis

In summary, Smaug was not sealed inside the Lonely Mountain but was rather a creature of great power and will who stayed for the treasure within. His freedom of movement is a critical aspect of the story, emphasizing the dragon's control over Erebor and the consequences of his actions.

For more in-depth analysis, it is essential to consider the dual nature of Smaug as a character: a treasure-loving dragon and a powerful being with the liberty to make choices. Understanding this can help in appreciating the complexities of the narrative and the fate of the Lonely Mountain.