Choosing Between Minilogue and DeepMind: A Comprehensive Guide

If you are in the market for a new synthesizer, two popular choices are the Minilogue by Korg and the DeepMind by Novation. Despite the plethora of options in the synth market, deciding between these two can be quite a challenge. This article aims to provide an unbiased and detailed comparison to help you make an informed decision.

Introduction

The decision of selecting between the Minilogue and the DeepMind truly depends on the specific features and sounds you are looking for in your synthesizer. Both instruments have their own unique selling points. This article delves into the features and sounds of each synth based on personal experience to help you make a better choice.

Why I Chose the Minilogue

I got the Minilogue over a year ago for a couple of reasons, the most compelling of which was the sound. To this day, there are no regrets. My primary belief is that the most crucial aspect of a synthesizer is its sound. A great sound can elevate what you can achieve with the instrument, making other technical aspects almost secondary.

Addressing Key Clicking Issues

Unlike some, I found the key clicking feature of the Minilogue both enjoyable and quite beneficial to my sound design. Some users have reported that keys can produce clicking sounds, but this is a simple issue to resolve. The EG (Envelope Generator) allows for minor adjustments to the attack and release parameters, which can easily be configured to eliminate the clicking. In fact, I sometimes deliberately emphasize the clicking by adjusting the EG parameters. Those who complain about this clicking may not have taken the time to learn their instrument's capabilities, much like expecting to instantly sound like a pro despite not having spent a lot of time with it.

The Issue of Tuning Drift

Another concern some users have is the issue of tuning drift, particularly in colder environments. The Minilogue does show a slight tuning drift in the first few minutes, but it stabilizes quite quickly. Unlike older synths that required hours to warm up, the Minilogue is a breeze to use right from the beginning. If the drift becomes a minor issue at a later stage, I've found it adds a character to the music without needing to be readjusted. In fact, I enjoy tuning it again as it can add a different flavor to the sound.

The Minilogue’s Defining Features

The Minilogue has an analogue effect built-in at the end of its audio path, a delay with a high-pass filter that can be used on its own. However, what's truly remarkable about this synth is its versatility. With cross modulation, ring modulation, oscillator sync, eight voice modes, unison detune, and wave shape control, the possibilities are endless. While I initially needed to practice to utilize these features, now I can create a vast array of effects simply by adjusting the appropriate parameters. One of my favorite tricks is feeding audio into the Minilogue at the mixer stage, leveraging its low-pass and high-pass filters as well as delay for other instruments. This adds a lot of flexibility and creativity to my sound design.

What About the DeepMind?

The DeepMind is certainly a good-looking synth and after a lot of listening and watching videos, it's clear that it has its merits. However, I found its sound rather clinical, which is not to everyone's taste. Some users might find it interesting, but my preference lies in a more organic, ethereal, or deep sound, which is where I believe the Minilogue excels.

Tech and User Interface Concerns

While the Minilogue's interface is forgiving and intuitive, the DeepMind seems more fiddly, requiring a lot of button pressing to achieve the desired effect. This can be an issue if you prefer a more hands-on approach to creating music where speed and flexibility are more important than meticulous control. For those who enjoy the technical side of things, the DeepMind might be just the right fit, but it's a step up from what I prefer as a musician looking to create music quickly and effortlessly.

Personal Preference and Additional Equipment

Personal preference plays a significant role when it comes to choosing between the Minilogue and the DeepMind. If you favor a more organic and versatile sound, the Minilogue would be an excellent choice. However, if you're okay with a more clinical sound that suits your style, you might prefer the DeepMind. I confess that even with the DeepMind, I found the sound to be less inspiring and more clinical, which is why I stuck with the Minilogue.

What to Consider Beyond the Basics

If you have the budget, another option worth considering is a classic Korg Polysix or Monopoly. These analog classics combined with a Roland TR-808 and a good quality reel-to-reel multitrack recorder can create a fantastic retro sound. Alternatives like the Moog One and modern digital synths may also be considered, but they tend to fall short in providing the same level of organic character that these classic instruments offer.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the choice between the Minilogue and the DeepMind ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize sound quality, versatility, and ease of use, the Minilogue might be the better choice. On the other hand, if you're ok with a more clinical sound and enjoy the technical aspects of creating music, the DeepMind could be perfect for you. Whichever you choose, remember that personal taste is a crucial factor, and you should prioritize the instrument that aligns with your artistic vision.