Why the Valar Waited for Erendil to Overthrow Morgoth

The decision of the Valar to wait for Erendil before taking action against Morgoth is a deeply intricate and thematic discussion. In J.R.R. Tolkien's Legendarium, it highlights the interplay between hope, free will, and the unfolding of fate.

Erendil's Unique Role

Erendil, a half-Elven character and the son of Tuor and Idril, is crucial in the narrative. His unique position among both Elves and Men gives him a unique role that was recognized by the Valar. As a symbol of the union between the two races, Erendil's journey to Valinor was not merely an appeal for help but a representation of the hope for unity against Morgoth. Erendil's actions were pivotal in rallying the support of both Elves and Men to meet the challenge of their greatest enemy.

The Nature of Free Will

The Valar respected the free will of the Children of Ilúvatar, recognizing that the struggle against Morgoth had to be led by the voluntary actions of Middle-earth's peoples. They believed that direct intervention by the Valar would undermine the free will of the races and hinder the natural development of their own destinies. Erendil's plea for aid was a testament to this free will, as his actions were essential in fostering the collective effort necessary to confront Morgoth.

The Timing of Intervention

Previous interventions by the Valar in Middle-earth had been hesitant, driven by a need for a compelling reason. By the time Erendil arrived, Morgoth had significantly increased his power, making it clear that a united front was required. Erendil's plea to the Valar served as the catalyst that prompted the Valar to take decisive action, marking a turning point in the fight against darkness.

The Significance of Erendil's Voyage

Erendil's journey to Valinor was a profound symbol of hope and redemption. His successful arrival and subsequent plea to the Valar represented a crucial moment in the struggle against evil. The Valar's decision to respond to Erendil's call for aid was also a response to the growing despair in Middle-earth, recognizing that Morgoth's reign of terror could no longer be ignored. This decision marked the beginning of the end for Morgoth and set the stage for the eventual unity of the races of Middle-earth.

In summary, the Valar's decision to wait for Erendil was contingent upon his unique heritage, the respect for free will, the necessity of a collective effort against Morgoth, and the symbolic significance of his journey. These elements combined to make Erendil's arrival a pivotal moment in Middle-earth's history, leading to the eventual downfall of Morgoth.