Why Fantasy Seem More Real Than Sci-Fi To Some

The perception that fantasy feels more real than science fiction to many individuals is intriguing, especially given that science offers a more reliable and factual understanding of the world. This article explores the psychological, emotional, and subjective dimensions that make fantasy resonate deeply with some individuals, while science remains purely objective and factual.

Understanding the Inner versus Outer Worlds

It is often suggested that fantasy is more impactful because it taps into the inner reality of the human experience, including emotions, psychological realms, metaphors, symbols, and mythic elements. In contrast, science focuses on the outer, physical world, seeking to understand how things work. While science is a reliable and effective tool for explaining the physical universe, it lacks the capability to address existential questions or provide inner meaning.

Science: The Objective Norm

Science is rigorous, systematic, and objective. It provides us with a verifiable understanding of how the world operates, but it leaves no room for personal interpretation or subjective meaning. When it comes to questions of life's meaning and purpose, science falls short. It cannot tell us what our lives mean because such questions transcend the boundaries of empirical science.

Fantasy: The Subjective Realm

Fantasy, on the other hand, delves into the subjective realm of human experience. It engages with concepts like imagination, mythos, emotion, and inner worlds. These elements provide avenues for finding or creating personal meaning and existential purpose. Fantasy offers a space for exploration, creativity, and emotional depth that stands in stark contrast to the objective and methodical nature of science.

The Personal Connection

The relationship between fantasy and science can vary significantly based on an individual's personal preferences and personality type. For instance, early experiences can shape one's inclination toward one direction or the other. My own journey was a blend of personal interests and environmental factors.

Personality and Interests

From a young age, I recognized a strong affinity for the Romantic side of the spectrum. This preference for fantasy and myth over a strict focus on science was evident even in my early childhood. Science intrigued me, particularly its grand ideas and theories, but I struggled with the detailed aspects of it in school. Conversely, I found the arts and humanities to be a natural fit, drawn to their overall essence and emotional resonance rather than formal rules.

The Countercultural Influence

The year 1967 played a significant role in shaping my perspective. During this time, the countercultural zeitgeist amplified my interest in fantasy and myth. The reading of The Odyssey alongside the introduction to The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien resonated deeply with me. This immersion in literature and mythic themes reinforced my appreciation for these elements.

The reading of Carl Jung's Man and His Symbols further solidified my interest in the psychological and symbolic aspects of myth and fantasy. Jung's work on the collective unconscious and individual psyche provided a framework to understand the deeper layers of personal meaning in these narratives.

A Balanced Perspective

It is important to recognize that personal preferences do not have to be mutually exclusive. While I have strong preferences and innate tendencies towards fantasy and myth, I also acknowledge the value of science in providing factual and reliable knowledge. Science has played a crucial role in my life, such as restoring my sight, and cannot be dismissed or underrated.

Navigating Between Worlds

Ultimately, the balance between fantasy and science depends on individual cognitive and emotional propensities. Some individuals may find greater meaning in the subjective realm of fantasy, while others may lean more towards the objective world of science. Recognizing the strengths and limitations of both perspectives can lead to a richer and more holistic understanding of the world.