Whose a Better Mythology Writer: Ashwin Sanghi or Amish Tripathi?

The debate over which author is the superior mythology writer between Ashwin Sanghi and Amish Tripathi has been a hot topic among readers and fans of Indian literature. Both authors have made significant contributions to the genre, each with a unique narrative style and approach to Hindu mythology. In this article, I will explore the strengths and weaknesses of both authors and ultimately throw my support behind Amish Tripathi.

Ashwin Sanghi: An Informative Yet Narrative Flawed Writer

Ashwin Sanghi is a name often associated with rich informational content about Hindu mythology in his works, such as The Krishna Key. While the factual accuracy and depth of information provided in his books are commendable, his narrative style falls short compared to his contemporary, Amish Tripathi.

One of the key issues with Ashwin Sanghi's writing is that his stories often bear a striking resemblance to famous Western works, such as Dan Brown's Angels and Demons. In The Krishna Key, there are numerous parallels with The Da Vinci Code. This repetitive and overused narrative framework can make his stories feel derivative and less engaging for readers.

Amish Tripathi: A Master of Plot and Narrative

Amish Tripathi, on the other hand, has stolen the show with his Shiva Trilogy, particularly the Meluha Series. His works, such as The Siege of Mandir and The Mark of the Porpoise, exemplify outstanding plot development, masterful narration, and a rich imagination that goes beyond mere information provision.

Tripathi's portrayal of characters like Ganesha, often seen as a mere deity or figure in temples, brings a completely new perspective to the audience. The depth of his research and the logical framework he creates around the epics provide a refreshing and engaging reading experience. Furthermore, his stories are filled with thrilling elements and emotional depth that captivate readers.

Comparing the Authors: A Deeper Dive

When it comes to depth in narration, Amish Tripathi has consistently demonstrated a superior approach compared to Ashwin Sanghi. While both authors have made significant contributions to the field of Hindu mythology, Tripathi's ability to weave complex narratives and maintain reader engagement is unparalleled. He has even admitted that when it comes to riveting and spine-chilling fiction, no other author can match Ashwin Sanghi's work, a testament to the latter's compelling storytelling.

Tripathi's Shiva Trilogy is a prime example of his narrative prowess. The trilogy, consisting of The Siege of Mandir, The Mark of the Porpoise, and The Battle of Stars, delves deep into the historical and mythological background, creating a rich tapestry of characters and plotlines. The war parts, character portrayals, and emotional depth are just a few aspects that set his works apart.

Personal Experience and Reflection

My decision to favor Amish Tripathi is based on firsthand experience with his works and Ashwin Sanghi's The Krishna Key. While I was intrigued by the concept of involving Kalki avatar in The Krishna Key, the novel's ending left me disappointed. I felt that Sanghi packed unnecessary and irrelevant details, which detracted from the overall narrative coherence.

Amish Tripathi's approach to re-telling epics is both logical and gripping. His works such as Scion of Ikshvaku infuse the narratives with a thriller element, making them highly engaging. Additionally, the emotional depth and personal experiences he conveys through his stories often leave a lasting impact on the reader.

Conclusion: A Clear Winner

In conclusion, while both Ashwin Sanghi and Amish Tripathi have made notable contributions to the field of Hindu mythology and fiction, Amish Tripathi clearly emerges as the superior writer. His ability to create a logical and engaging narrative, coupled with his deep research and creative imagination, sets him apart from his contemporaries. Whether it's the rich portrayal of characters or the intricate plot development, Tripathi's works consistently provide a superior reading experience.

References and Further Reading:

Shiva: Battle of Stars by Amish Tripathi Kalki by Ashwin Sanghi