Where Have All the Mythical Creatures Gone in a Modern Middle-earth?

In a modern version of J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth, the disappearance of legendary creatures such as living mountains, elves, and dragons can be explained through several compelling theories rooted in the evolution and transformation of our world.

The Aging of the World

One plausible explanation for the absence of these mythical beings is the gradual waning of magic and the magical aspects of the world as it advances. This theory aligns with Tolkien's own narrative, where the decline of magical elements is a key theme. As civilizations grow more advanced and technological, the diminished presence of magic could lead to the fading or disappearance of these creatures.

Isolation and Seclusion

Many mythical beings, such as the living mountain and elves, might have chosen to retreat to hidden realms or secluded areas. This mirrors the behavior of the Elves in Tolkien's stories, who often reside in remote locations sheltered from the prying eyes of humanity. These creatures could now exist in places that are inaccessible or forgotten by modern society, leaving only remnants of their existence in folklore and art.

Integration into Folklore and Memory

Another theory is that these creatures have become part of folklores and myths, inspiring stories and legends. While they may no longer reside in the physical realm, their influence can be felt through literature, art, and culture. The continued fascination with these beings in the modern world serves as a testament to their lasting impact on human imagination and belief.

Conflict and Change

There could have been conflicts between humans and mythical creatures that led to their decline or extinction. As industrialization and modernization progressed, natural habitats were destroyed, forcing these beings to adapt or perish. The hobbits, for instance, might have been hunted to extinction by humans, reinforcing the theme of the world's changing dynamics and the challenges faced by these creatures.

Transformation and Integration with Nature

Some mythical beings might have undergone transformation, merging with nature or taking on new forms. For example, a living mountain could have become a geographical feature embodying the spirit of the mountain, rather than a sentient entity. This transformation would allow these beings to remain in the landscape, influencing the natural world in ways that are both tangible and intangible.

Cultural Shifts and Belief

As societies evolve, the appreciation and belief in magic and mythical creatures might also change. This shift could lead to a loss of recognition of these beings, making it increasingly difficult for them to exist in a world that no longer prioritizes their significance. However, the remnants of these creatures can still influence culture, art, and literature, serving as a reminder of a time when magic was more tangible and prevalent.

In this modern version of Middle-earth, the elves are the most notable exception, with many having either passed over the sea or faded if they remained in Middle-earth. Despite their physical absence, they continue to influence the world in a spiritual form, inspiring stories and myths. The hobbits, on the other hand, could have fallen victim to human expansion, leading to their extinction or near-extinction.

The absence of these mythical creatures in a modern Middle-earth can be seen as a reflection of the changing relationship between humans and the natural world. Their presence or absence serves as a poignant reminder of the delicate balance between magic and reality and the profound impact that cultural and environmental change can have on the world we inhabit.