The Tragic Exile of Finwe with Feanor: A Journey of Corruption and Betrayal

Within J.R.R. Tolkien's expansive The Silmarillion, the tragic tale of Finwe's exile with his brother, Feanor, unfolds as a complex narrative of mistrust, jealousy, and the drive for power. This article delves into the origins and consequences of this pivotal moment in the history of the Noldor, the descendants of F?anor, and the events that led to their tragic journey.

Roots of Paranoia and Distrust

Finwe's exile with Feanor is deeply rooted in the events of Tolkien's legendarium, particularly surrounding the return of Melkor (also known as Morgoth) to Valinor. The Noldor, who had settled in Valinor under the protection of the Valar, had grown increasingly wary of potential threats. Feanor, being the eldest, became increasingly distrustful and secretive, believing that the Valar would not protect the Noldor from Melkor's impending doom.

Feanor's paranoia was further exacerbated when he managed to stir dissent among the Noldor, a tactic skillfully employed by Melkor to sow discord. The pivotal moment leading to Finwe's exile occurred when Feanor manipulated Finwe into believing that he could not trust anyone, including the Valar themselves. This manipulation was a key factor in Feanor's (and subsequently Finwe's) decision to leave Valinor.

The Creation of the Silmarils and Envy

Following his creation of the Silmarils, the most beautiful and powerful jewels in existence, Feanor's envy and desire for the jewels grew. Melkor, driven by his own malice and desire for the Silmarils, poisoned Feanor's heart, further fueling the rivalry and conflict between the Noldor and Melkor.

After Melkor stole the Silmarils and killed Finwe during the Battle of Unnumbered Tears, the Noldor were driven to seek revenge and reclaim what was lost. Feanor, filled with anger and grief, declared that the Noldor should leave Valinor and pursue Melkor to Middle-earth. This decision marked the beginning of the Noldors' exile, with Feanor leading the way, driven by a mix of vengeance and ambition.

Legitimacy and Corruption

Despite Feanor's illegitimate authority, supported by his eldest son, Fingolfin, Finwe still chose to follow him into exile. In the Silmarillion, it is noted that Finwe was joined by his seven sons and a strong place and treasury was made in the hills of Formenos. The Silmarils were kept in an iron chamber, and Finwe himself sought to join Feanor out of love for him.

The Allegiance of Fingolfin

Fingolfin, despite being a son of Finwe, swore allegiance to Feanor before the throne of Manw?, affirming his commitment to follow where Feanor goes. This decision was partly influenced by his sons, who urged him on. However, Fingolfin was hesitant to leave Valinor, fearing the ill-advised counsels of his brother and the fate that befalls his people.

When Feanor abandoned him, Fingolfin's desire to reach Middle-earth intensified. He wished to meet Feanor again, driven by a mix of stubborn loyalty and a desperate hope to repair the damage caused by the betrayal.

Conclusion

The exile of Finwe with Feanor serves as a poignant reminder of the dangers of misplaced trust, the destructive nature of envy, and the consequences of unchecked ambition. This tale is a critical part of Tolkien's legendarium, illustrating the fallibility of even the most noble and powerful beings in the face of corruption and treachery. It is through understanding these themes that one can better appreciate the depth and complexity of Tolkien's creation.