The Reaction of the Valar When Fanor Refused to Give Up His Silmarils

The ancient history of the Quenya mythos is rich with complex moral and ethical dilemmas. One of the most compelling and often debated episodes is the reaction of the Valar when Fanor, an elf-smith, refused to give up the Silmarils to save the Two Trees from Morgoth's corruption. This story reveals much about the differing perspectives and moral stances of both the Valar and the Elves, and provides valuable insights into the concept of free will and the limits of divine authority.

Background and Context

Amidst the early epochs of Middle-earth, the Valar created the Two Trees of Telperion and Laurelin, the source of much of the world's light. Eventually, Melkor, theDark Lord, sought to corrupt and destroy these arboreal masterpieces. Faced with this threat, the Valar decided that the Silmarils, the gemstones created by Feanor, could be the key to preserving the light of the Trees from Morgoth's malevolent power. However, their plan was met with fierce resistance from Fanor, who cherished his creations more than life itself.

Feeling of Resignation and Outrage

Fe?nor's response to the Valar's request was marked by a mix of resignation and outrage. He clearly saw the Valar's demand as an unjustified imposition, and he felt that his right to keep his creations intact was being challenged. Fe?nor's attitude can be seen in his response: 'I would not willingly part with the Silmarils,' he said, implying that even force was not a viable option. The Valar, understanding the depth of Fe?nor's emotional attachment, respected his decision, even though they knew it meant the doom of the Two Trees.

However, the request also strained relations between the Valar and Fanor. Fanor felt that the Valar were treating him as an adversary, rather than a partner or friend. His sentiments were heartfelt and genuine: 'It is asking me to destroy my life's work, something I could never recreate,' he lamented. This was not just a mere gem but a manifestation of his own craftsmanship and artistry.

Valar's Response and Mandos' Words

Despite Fanor's stance, the Valar maintained their respect and understanding. Tulkas, in his rush for a definitive decision, pushed Fanor to give in, which only increased the tension. Aul, the primordial smith, called for patience and understanding, knowing the gravity of the situation.

After much deliberation and emotional turmoil, Fanor declared with a heavy heart, 'You'll have to force me to do it, and if you do, you are just as bad as Melkor.' This was a hurtful statement, reflecting on the Valar's inability to comprehend the depth of the loss Fe?nor felt. Námo Mandos, the Valar who kept the memory of ages, merely said, 'Thou has spoken.' It was a simple acknowledgment that Fanor's choice was his own and that the Valar respected it, no matter the consequence.

Literature and Cultural Impact

This episode in the greater narrative of Middle-earth has had a significant impact on literature and culture. The story underscores the importance of free will and the limits of divine intervention. It highlights the tension between the desire to protect and preserve and the sanctity of individual choices.

Keyword: Silmarils, Valar, Fanor, Trees of Light, Morgoth

Image Credit: Soni Alcorn