The Origin and Evolution of 'The Old College Try'

Have you ever heard the phrase 'the old college try'? This American idiom, often used in sports contexts, captures the spirit of effort and determination, especially when facing seemingly impossible tasks. Let's delve into its origins and how it became an integral part of American sports vocabulary.

The Phrase and Its Contexts

The term 'the old college try' likely draws its meaning from the spirited and determined efforts that students put into their studies and activities during their college years. It reflects a sense of camaraderie and perseverance, encapsulating a nostalgic view of college life and emphasizing the importance of putting forth one's best efforts.

While the exact origin is difficult to pinpoint, the phrase has been associated with the sporting world, particularly in the context of college athletics. Teams and individuals often embody the spirit of hard work and determination, regardless of the outcome of the game.

The Early Usage of 'The Old College Try'

The phrase first gained popularity in the world of baseball. It was used to describe a fielder making a desperate attempt to catch a ball, even when the outcome seemed impossible. The term suggests a hint of showboating, a wild and desperate attempt to make a play, often leading to a futile effort.

Early Examples of 'The Old College Try' in Baseball

One of the earliest recorded usages of 'the old college try' can be found in a New York Commercial article published on 16 October 1912. The piece recounts a game where a contrary hit by Wagner's ball appeared uncatchable:

“Snodgrass Has Redeemed Himself” pg. 5 col. 4:

In another instance from Lancaster Daily Intelligencer on 5 July 1913, the phrase is used to describe a youthful first baseman's attempt at fielding a foul ball:

“News from the World of Sports” pg. 6 col. 2:
“McGraw one time had a college first baseman on trial. A foul was hit a mile over the grandstand but the collegian tore after it cap gone and hair flying. “Ah well” said McGraw dryly as the youth came back to his bag “he gave it the old college try.”

Similarly, the Kalamazoo Gazette on 24 August 1913, repeats the usage in a slightly different context, adding to its historical narrative:

“College Education No Aid on Diamond Declare Pilots” pg. 11 col. 2:
“McGraw once had a college first baseman on trial. A foul was hit a mile over the grandstand but the collegian tore after it cap gone and hair flying. “Ah well” said McGraw wearily as the youth came back to his bag “he gave it the old college try.”

Popularization in Sports and Beyond

The term 'the old college try' has since become a common idiom in American English. It is often used to describe a desperate or determined effort, especially in sports contexts. The phrase has a distinct meaning when associated with the Giants, as evidenced by a quote from a piece written by Billy Sunday in 1917:

“The Old College Try”
By BILLY SUNDAY
“But McGraw Wiser than Any of them said:
‘That the Eye Young Fellow—The Old College Try!’
And ever since then when an Ambitious Athlete goes after a Hard One the Giants call it “The Old College Try.”
‘They Miss Most of Them don’t they Mac’ somebody asked him.
‘Yes’ answered the Cagey Chieftain—‘but it would Jolt You to see how Many they Grab!’

The term is not limited to baseball. It has been used in various contexts, such as in Oregonian on 31 May 1915, where it describes a player's desperate attempt to maintain his performance, and in Sioux City Journal on 17 June 1917, where it is employed to add humor and character to a sports article.

Conclusion

'The old college try' is a testament to the spirit of perseverance and effort in sports. It captures the essence of an athlete striving to give their best, even in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds. The phrase has a rich history, particularly in baseball, and continues to be used in modern sports contexts, embodying the values of determination and hard work.