The Boys vs Invincible: A Comparison of Dystopian Superhero Series

When it comes to choosing between The Boys and Invincible, many viewers find Invincible more challenging to engage with due to its complex narrative and gradually unfolding plot. However, both series excel in presenting a dark and cynical take on the superhero genre. Let's delve into what makes Invincible a worthwhile watch despite its early struggles to capture an audience.

Defining the Terminology

Neither series is typically labeled as a 'dystopian' series, at least not in the traditional sense. Both, however, share a Superman-reimagining perspective that treads the line between the idealistic and the realistic. This perspective can be termed anti-Superman, where the central superhero character is not perfect, making them more relatable and flawed.

The Boys: A Corporate Greed-Based Superhero

The Boys, created by Eric Kripke, presents a world where superheroes are not only corrupt but openly abuse their powers. The main antagonist, Homelander, is a charismatic and villainous character who embodies the purity of dark corporate greed. This contrast between the Superman ideal and the real world is a core theme of the series.

Invincible: An Alien Superhero and the Evolution of Humanity

Invincible, authored by Robert Kirkman and Cory Walker, introduces Omni-Man, a visitor from another planet who initially masquerades as a hero, only to reveal his true intentions as a conqueror. The series focuses on Mark Grayson, Omni-Man's son, who struggles with the morality of his father's actions. Mark's journey parallels the Superman archetype, yet without the idealized perfection.

Narrative Structure and Complexity

Invincible's narrative introduces several standardized plot elements found in many superhero origin stories, such as Mark's conflict with Todd, a bully. Yet, the story twists this convention by showing Mark choosing not to stand up to the bully with his powers. This detail highlights the complexity and depth of Invincible.

Engagement and Plot Progression

Despite its initial challenges, Invincible offers a unique perspective on the evolution of a hero. The first season examines the improbability of a Superman-like character emerging from Mark's perspective. As the series progresses, it explores themes of power, morality, and the cost of heroism.

Visual and Relatability

The early episodes of Invincible feature poor animation, which can detract from the viewing experience. Additionally, some characters, like Zazie Beetz, bring a level of relatability and subtle depth to the show. While the animation and some characters initially pose challenges, the storyline and character evolution offer plenty of rewards for patient viewers.

If you find Invincible harder to get into, I'd recommend watching the series with a focus on its unique themes and how it subverts typical superhero narratives. The show will take you on a wild ride, exploring the messy reality of a 'Superman' figure without the glossy polish of traditional superhero content.

By understanding the anti-Superman perspective in both The Boys and Invincible, you can better appreciate the intricate and thought-provoking nature of these series. Whether you start with Invincible or The Boys, both offer a compelling look at what happens when superheroes aren't infallible.