Literature
Shirou Emiyas Destiny in Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works - Can He Avoid Becoming a Counter Guardian EMIYA?
Shirou Emiya's Destiny in Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works - Can He Avoid Becoming a Counter Guardian EMIYA?
In Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works (UBW), Shirou Emiya's journey is a poignant exploration of idealism, heroism, and the consequences of one's choices. By the end of UBW, Shirou makes a conscious choice to forge his own path, rejecting the burden of the Counter Guardian's role, which is embodied by the darker, more jaded version of himself known as EMIYA.
Themes of Idealism and Heroism
The narrative of UBW delves into the complex themes of idealism, heroism, and the ethical dilemmas of becoming a Counter Guardian. Counter Guardians are summoned to correct the imbalances in the world, often at significant cost to their humanity and ideals. Shirou's resolve to uphold his own ideals and create a future that allows him to protect others without succumbing to the cycles of violence and regret that define EMIYA's existence is a pivotal turning point in the story.
Shirou's Conscious Choice
Shirou's conscious decision to uphold his ideals and seek a different future rather than becoming a Counter Guardian underscores his commitment to his own journey. Unlike the darker version of himself, EMIYA, Shirou is determined to craft his own identity and destiny. He does not merely aim to save others; he strives to do so without losing sight of his core values and human essence.
The Role of Fate and Shirou's Will
It is worth noting that in the context of the series, it is explicitly stated that while there is a chance for Shirou to become a Counter Guardian, the likelihood is so low that it might as well be zero percent. This is evident in Nasu's comments suggesting that Shirou's journey is one of self-discovery and growth, rather than a predetermined path.
Shirou's Reception of Arche's Legacy
Archer's journey serves as a cautionary tale for Shirou, highlighting the dangers of becoming a Counter Guardian and succumbing to the jaded, bitter existence embodied by EMIYA. Unlike Archer, Shirou has learned from his mistakes and is not content to follow a path he does not fully embrace. He is willing to fail, as long as he tries his best and remains true to his ideals.
Multiple Outcomes and Personal Growth
In Fate/Stay Night, Shirou may encounter different outcomes depending on the route he takes. In Avalon, he may reach Avalon after death, and in Sakura's route, he may give up on his ideals. However, the UBW timeline presents a unique journey where Shirou does not immediately succumb to the jaded and resigned outlook of EMIYA. Instead, he remains more positive, perhaps even sunnier and more accepting of his role in the greater narrative, as seen in F/GO where EMIYA is depicted as a more optimistic figure willing to accept his counter guardian duties.
Conclusion
While there is a possibility for Shirou to become a Counter Guardian, the narrative of Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works firmly positions him as an individual who will take his own path, guided by the ideals he has learned to love and respect. Shirou's journey is one of personal growth, resilience, and the strength to carve out his own destiny, free from the shadows of the Counter Guardian's curse.