Magical Realism vs. Bad Fantasy: Differentiating Between the Two in Writing

It’s kinda like Pronography: Difficult to define but you know it when you try to read it.

Bad Fantasy is when you find yourself not caring if you never read past chapter 1. But it's not all about surface-level enjoyment; it's about the quality and depth of the writing. Today, we'll explore the differences between magical realism and bad fantasy in writing and discuss how to distinguish between the two.

What is Magical Realism?

First and foremost, it's important to understand that magic/magical realism is not automatically 'bad.' Magical realism is a literary genre that blends magical or fantastical elements with a realistic narrative and setting. It’s not about the inclusion of magic or fantasy elements; it’s about how these elements integrate into the story and what they represent within the context of the narrative. Magical realism convinces us that sometimes reality truly is stranger and more complex than our perceived world.

Characteristics of Magical Realism

In magical realism, the fantastical elements are so seamlessly integrated into the narrative that they become a natural part of the world in the story. These elements don't require an explanation; they are accepted as a part of everyday life, much like the weather or the passing of time. Think about Gabriel García Márquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude, where strange occurrences like a man turning into an edible bird are just another aspect of life in the fictional town of Macondo.

Examples of Magical Realism

One notable example of magical realism is The Hanging Garden by Claire Vaye Watkins, where a young gay man returns home more than a decade after his suicide. This story doesn’t require an explanation for the magical elements like a Mandela Effect—it accepts them as a part of the reality of the story. This story could easily fit into a category like Science Fiction or even Fantasy, but it’s magical realism because it’s rooted in our world with a blend of the extraordinary and the ordinary.

What is Bad Fantasy?

On the other hand, bad fantasy is often characterized by its poor execution and lack of depth. In bad fantasy, the fantastical elements are so contrived that they detract from the overall narrative and fail to engage the reader. A story that you find yourself not caring if you never read past chapter 1 is a clear sign of subpar fantasy writing. This is because the author might overuse tropes, have unrealistic world-building, or lack character development, making the story difficult to engage with.

Characteristics of Bad Fantasy

Bad fantasy often lacks coherence and depth. The magical or fantastical elements might be too confusing or poorly integrated, leading to a disconnect between the reader and the story. When a story is written in bad fantasy style, it often feels like the author is padding their work with irrelevant or excessive magical elements, ignoring the core elements of character and plot development. For example, if a story about a young wizard performing spells without any explanation or consequences, it might fall into the category of bad fantasy due to its superficial handling of magic.

Distinguishing Between Magical Realism and Bad Fantasy

The key to distinguishing between magical realism and bad fantasy lies in how well the story integrates its fantastical elements. In magical realism, the magic is a natural part of the world, and the story flows seamlessly with the narrative. In bad fantasy, the magic or other fantastical elements are often overused or poorly integrated, leading to a disjointed and unengaging story.

Key Differences

Magic in the World: In magical realism, the magic is a natural part of the world, not an interference. In bad fantasy, the magic might be overly contrived or distract from the story. Character Development: Magical realism often features rich, dynamic characters who navigate their world, including the magical elements. In bad fantasy, characters might be one-dimensional or lack depth, overshadowed by the magical elements. World-Building: In magical realism, the world is meticulously built, with the fantastical elements naturally fitting into the narrative. In bad fantasy, world-building might be superficial, leading to an unrealistic and disjointed world. Reader Engagement: Readers in magical realism are engaged throughout the story, willing to follow the fantastical elements expecting them to fit into the larger narrative. In bad fantasy, readers are likely to become disengaged due to poor narrative flow or lack of coherent magic or world-building.

Conclusion

The difference between magical realism and bad fantasy is like pronography: it can be difficult to define, but you know it when you see it. Magical realism invites you into a world where the fantastical and the real blend seamlessly, creating a rich and meaningful narrative. Bad fantasy, on the other hand, often lacks the depth and coherence necessary to engage the reader fully. By understanding these nuances, writers and readers can better appreciate and evaluate the stories they encounter.

Related Keywords

magical realism bad fantasy writing styles