Lady Barbrey Dustin: A Lady with Hidden Allegiances in 'A Dance with Dragons'

Is it plausible that Lady Barbrey Dustin is safeguarding Ned Stark's bones, as suggested by the characters in 'A Dance with Dragons'? Let's explore the evidence and consider what we know about her character and allegiances.

Barbrey’s Convictions and Skepticism

One cannot help but feel that Lady Barbrey's conversation with Theon Greyjoy is too honest, suggesting she may be hiding something or even lying. There's a grudge against Catelyn and Rickard, but not against Brandon Stark, who was known to be fine with marrying Catelyn and had even started an affair with Ashara Dayne at Harrenhal. Additionally, her timeline is questionable, with her father suggesting a match between her and Ned Stark after Catelyn's marriage to Rickard took place. This timeline is inconsistent as Ned and Catelyn’s marriage was after Barbrey's marriage to William.

Barbrey's Allegiances and the Significance of Her Actions

A closer look at Lady Barbrey's actions and allegiances reveals a complex web of loyalties. She works for the Starks, which is evident from the foreshadowing of snowmen resembling women who are Stark loyalists. Harwood and Wyman Manderly, both of whom have close ties to Barbrey, are known Stark supporters. The fact that Barbrey asked Theon to show her to the crypts has significant implications. The crypts are notable for missing swords taken at the end of 'A Clash of Kings', and the authentication of Osha’s sword suggests a connection between Barbrey, Harwood, and the chain of crows, all supporting the idea that Barbrey has valuable insider information.

Barbrey’s Ongoing Conflict with the Boltons

Barbrey’s hatred for Ramsay Bolton is deeply rooted, stemming from the Red Wedding, where many of her kin and men lost their lives. Her only connection to them is through her sister's marriage to Roose Bolton, who also died years ago, leaving her with no personal connection. This makes it clear that she has every reason to oppose the Boltons and work against them.

Conclusion: The Possibility of Safeguarding Ned Stark’s Bones

Given the evidence, it wouldn't be a leap to consider the possibility that Lady Barbrey could be safeguarding Ned Stark's bones. Her many reasons to oppose the Boltons, her close connections to Stark loyalists, and the crypt episode all point to her having a significant role in the story. If the Hooded Man is indeed Hal Mollen, it further strengthens the idea that Lady Barbrey has valuable information or items, such as Ned Stark's bones, that she is protecting.