What if Jon Snow Had Inherited the Targaryen Look?

Imagine a world where Jon Snow, the controversial hero of A Song of Ice and Fire series, bore the Targaryen features rather than the Stark ones. This simple change would have profound implications for identity, politics, and the overall narrative of George R.R. Martin's masterpiece. Let's explore how this alternate scenario would reshape the Seven Kingdoms and the lives of its most prominent figures.

Identity and Legitimacy

From the beginning, Jon Snow's identity has been a source of great tension and intrigue. If he had inherited the Targaryen look, the doubt surrounding his parentage would have been even more pronounced, setting off a chain of events that would significantly alter the series' trajectory.

Ned Stark's Dilemma

Ned Stark would find himself in a very complicated situation. The scrutiny and suspicion surrounding Jon's true parentage would be immediate and intense. Ned's dedication to honor and truth would be put to the ultimate test. His claim that Jon was his bastard may have to be re-examined, making his loyalty and actions even more scrutinized:

Increased Threat from the Lannisters: The Lannisters, particularly Cersei and Jaime, would likely see Jon as a more pressing threat. They might act more aggressively to eliminate this potential rival to their power. Strain on Ned's Honor: Ned’s unwavering commitment to truth and honor would be severely tested. Finding new ways to justify his claim to Jon while maintaining his integrity would be a daunting task.

Jon's Sense of Self

Growing up with the Targaryen features would significantly impact Jon's self-identity. Always a bastard, Jon has been constantly reminded of his outsider status. However, now his appearance is also a source of self-doubt and confusion. He might struggle with feelings of not belonging, particularly in Winterfell:

Misplaced Identity: Jon’s bastards status would still apply, but the Targaryen look might make him feel even more out of place in the Stark household. Constant Reminders: He would be constantly reminded of his supposed status as a bastard, leading to a deeper sense of alienation.

Political Implications

Rhaegar Targaryen's Legacy

The acknowledgment of Jon's Targaryen heritage could reignite discussions about Rhaegar Targaryen’s legacy and the legitimacy of his children. These implications would likely reshape the political landscape and lead to:

Support from Targaryen Loyalists: Those loyal to the Targaryens might rally around Jon as a legitimate heir, increasing his power base. This could lead to conflicts with other factions. Tension with Daenerys: If Jon were openly recognized as a Targaryen, Daenerys might see him as a rival for the Iron Throne, creating tension between them. The Rebel Alliance: The dynamics of alliances could shift. Characters like Stannis Baratheon who seek to legitimize their own claims to the throne may view Jon as a valuable ally or a dangerous rival.

Character Relationships

Lyanna Stark's Role

The story might delve deeper into Lyanna Stark's motivations for protecting him. The mystery surrounding his birth would now be more about the implications of his Targaryen heritage rather than simply hiding his identity.

Sansa and Arya's Dynamics

Jon's differences in appearance might affect his relationships with his Stark siblings. Sansa and Arya may feel more alienated from him, complicating their familial bond:

New Bonds: The dynamic between Jon and his other siblings might shift, leading to new and sometimes strained relationships. Marcial Rivalry: The feelings of alienation might lead to a more complex power struggle within the Stark household.

Thematic Elements

Identity and Belonging

The theme of identity and belonging would take center stage. Jon’s journey would explore the dichotomy between Stark and Targaryen legacies, leading him to reconcile his dual heritage. This theme would resonate throughout the series, making Jon’s character development more profound:

Fate and Prophecy

Thoros of Myr's prophecy that Jon would bring winter to the Seven Kingdoms might gain new layers of meaning. His connection to Rhaegar and the Targaryen line would be a crucial element in the series' ongoing struggle to determine the fate of the Seven Kingdoms.

Conclusion

In summary, if Jon Snow had inherited the Targaryen look, the series would be dramatically altered. New conflicts would arise, reshaping the dynamics of character relationships and intensifying the political intrigue. The tale would explore deeper layers of identity, legitimacy, and the complex legacy of the Targaryens versus the Starks. This rich and intricate narrative would create a more profound and nuanced exploration of the series' themes, leading to a richer and more engaging story.