Literature
If Star Wars Was Originally a Book: Would It Still Be Science Fiction?
Would Star Wars Remain Science Fiction if Initially a Book?
Imagine a world where our beloved Star Wars saga didn't start with a series of movies but rather as a book. Does this scenario change its genre classification? In this article, we explore the intriguing question of how Star Wars would fare as a book and delve into its potential genre, ultimately concluding whether it would still be classified as Science Fiction.
Origins of Star Wars: A Book?
The idea for Star Wars, if originally a book, would be quite different from the familiar saga we know. George Lucas’s initial concept, titled "Journal of the Whills," had few similarities to the movies. However, the concept developed significantly when Lucas met a young science fiction writer named Alan Dean Foster.
Foster's novel idea involved an orphan boy with psychic powers, an elderly space knight, a pirate, a sarcastic beautiful woman, and an all-powerful weapon. This outline is strikingly similar to the Star Wars story we know today. In actuality, Foster co-wrote the novelization of Star Wars and the novel The Splinter of the Mind's Eye, which inspired aspects of Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi.
Verdict: Science Fiction?
Given these facts, it's clear that if Star Wars was originally a book, it would still be classified as Science Fiction. The original novel by Alan Dean Foster and the subsequent EU books heavily influence the story elements, such as the orphan character, psychic powers, an all-powerful weapon, and the overarching quest. These elements are quintessential to the genre of science fiction.
The Role of Fantasy Elements
While Star Wars has significant fantasy elements, such as wizards, magic swords, and an all-powerful weapon, the core science fiction aspects are still prominent. This makes the saga a blend of space fantasy rather than pure fantasy. In its movie form, it is classified as Space Fantasy because it combines traditional fantasy tropes with a space setting, elevated plot devices, and a mix of futuristic and supernatural elements.
Confusion Around Genre
The genre classification of Star Wars has been subject to debate, with terms like Space Opera and Science Fantasy often used. While these subgenres exist and are relevant, they are different from pure science fiction. Space Opera often involves sweeping space adventures and political intrigue, while Science Fantasy focuses on the fantasy elements, especially when they are rooted in futuristic technology.
Hard vs. Soft Science Fiction
Star Wars could be considered a form of soft science fiction, where the science is more about enabling the plot rather than being the central focus. In contrast, hard science fiction strives to adhere rigorously to scientific principles and explanations.
The terms Space Opera, Science Fantasy, and subgenres of Science Fiction are more relevant now, as they emerged later. The original 1970s term for this type of story might have been Space Opera. However, the core elements of science fiction, such as technological advancements and futuristic settings, remain present in Star Wars.
Conclusion
Despite the significant fantasy elements, if Star Wars was originally a book, it would undoubtedly fall under the category of Science Fiction. While the genre blend creates an unique blend known as Space Fantasy, the fundamental science fiction elements remain. The genre classification is ultimately a matter of perspective and interpretation, but for the most part, Star Wars would remain in the realm of science fiction.