Has Sansa Stark Told Arya about Theon Greyjoy's Deeds?

In the vast and intricate tapestry of A Song of Ice and Fire series, many untold stories and hidden truths await discovery. One such mystery is whether Sansa Stark has divulged to her sister, Arya Stark, all the things Theon Greyjoy has done. This question resonates with depth, especially considering their complex relationship and significant plot points from the show's narrative.

Unseen Conversations and Unfolding Tensions

During the portrayal of Sansa and Arya’s relationship, there is a clear tension that has been a significant plot point. While the camera shows their mutual frustration and occasional conflict, their real discussions and consultations with Bran have not been captured on screen. These off-screen conversations likely covered much more than what we see on screen. Given the complexity of their shared endeavors and their plans to rescue Rickon Stark, their detailed plans and strategies would naturally involve Theon Greyjoy, especially in light of the plot against Lord Petyr Baelish.

Both Sansa and Arya are intelligent and deeply involved in their family's vigil. Their conversations with Bran add depth to their characters and their plans. Bran's perspective often provides a crucial and secret element that informs their actions. It would be reasonable to assume that they would share information about Theon’s activities, as these actions affect their shared goals and their sibling responsibility.

Other Pressing Matters and Warmth Building

It is also worth noting that in the early stages of their reunion, there were more pressing matters. The initial reconciliation and the establishment of trust and friendship took time. Their genuine warmth for each other developed gradually, driven by a shared struggle, common enemies, and personal vendettas. Therefore, it is plausible that their initial conversations focused more on immediate concerns and personal grudges rather than extensive discussions about the past actions of Theon Greyjoy.

Assumptions and the Showrunners' Perspective

The assumption of whether Sansa has told Arya about Theon can be guided by the showrunners’ intent. They often leave room for us to make reasonable assumptions based on the context and character development. For instance, the death of Rickon Stark raised questions about how and why it happened. If Sansa and Arya didn’t communicate about it, it would seem highly unlikely given Arya’s keen observational skills and her role as a skilled assassin.

Arya’s role as an empathetic and analytical character also means that she would be aware of Theon’s role in the Stark family’s past tragedies through various means, such as her training and her own intelligence. Whether she has a definitive conversation with Sansa about Theon’s deeds remains a mystery, but it is a reasonable assumption that such conversations occurred off-screen.

Redemption and Continual Development

Furthermore, there is a possibility that Theon Greyjoy will undergo more significant redemptive arcs. His status as a character with a redeemable quality and a potential for change is evident. Bran’s existence alone is a clear signal that Theon did not kill Arya’s brothers. Bran's role in the show provides a crucial character development point that helps Arya understand Theon’s actions better.

Arya is a character who values justice and closure, and until Theon continues on his journey of redemption and provides Arya with a reason to de-prioritize him, the likelihood of her forgiveness and reconciliation remains low. The continuing development of Theon’s character and his journey towards redemption will play a significant role in Arya’s perception and internal dialogue about him.

In conclusion, while we cannot definitively state whether Sansa has told Arya about Theon’s deeds, it is a plausible assumption based on the character dynamics, the importance of information exchange, and the show’s narrative. Whether it is revealed on screen or remains an off-screen secret, Theon’s past actions and the ongoing development of his character will continue to influence the sisters' relationship and the narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire.