Exploring the Controversy and Width of "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn" in School Libraries

Introduction to "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn"

The works of Mark Twain, particularly "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn", are often a subject of debate in school libraries and curricula. My personal experience growing up in an international school system suggests these books were quite popular. However, the interpretation and application of these classics can vary widely depending on the school and the students' backgrounds.

Popularity and Accessibility in International Schools

In my school days, "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn" were part of the curriculum rather than hidden from the students. These books were openly available in our library, and no one seemed to see them as inappropriate. This is reflective of the diverse student body, which included students from all over the world. However, if your school library is more traditional or conservative, it might be beneficial to inquire about the availability of these books or their replacements.

Editing and Current Controversies

It's worth noting that some edited versions of these classics may be available in libraries. In fact, many school libraries still include these works, albeit sometimes with content modifications to suit the evolving standards of educational discourse. For instance, the use of certain linguistic elements in "Huckleberry Finn", particularly the controversial recurring phrase, can be a point of contention. Even when viewed in historical context, this word can be simultaneously acceptable and highly offensive depending on the speaker, much like the scenario in the movie Coach Carter.

The Issue of Racism and Classifications

Recent years have seen several stories about liberal teachers or school boards removing these books from the library shelves with no clear explanation given. When questioned, proponents of these actions often cite the books' portrayal of racism as their reason for banning them. Despite these efforts, these works remain widely available in most libraries, including school libraries, due to their status as classics.

Why Classics Should Remain Unrestricted

As classics, "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn" should be allowed in school libraries. These works offer valuable insights into American culture, history, and literature. Any ban on these books in favor of more 'revised' versions not only limits the scope of educational materials but also misrepresents the progressive nature of the community that often demands these changes.

Conclusion

It is highly improbable that "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn" will be permanently banned. As long as there is a demand for these classics, they will continue to be included in school curricula and library collections. Any perceived inappropriateness can be addressed through careful editing and discussion, rather than outright banning. Moreover, the diversity of viewpoints in literature encourages students to engage critically with the content, fostering a deeper understanding of the complexities of history and culture.