Exploring the Best and Worst Theories of A Song of Ice and Fire/ Game of Thrones

Theories surrounding A Song of Ice and Fire (ASOIAF) and its adaptation Game of Thrones (GoT) have sparked extensive discussion among fans. This article will explore some of the most popular and intriguing theories as well as those that have been met with skepticism.

Popular Theories

RLJ: Rhaegar Targaryen Lyanna Stark Jon Snow

Explanation: This theory posits that Jon Snow is actually the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark, making him a legitimate Targaryen heir. It was confirmed in the show but remains a pivotal theory in the books.

Popularity: Widely accepted as it aligns with character arcs and has significant implications for the story.

The Prince That Was Promised / Azor Ahai Reborn

Explanation: This theory suggests that a hero will arise to combat the darkness, often speculated to be Jon Snow or Daenerys Targaryen.

Popularity: The theory is intriguing and ties into various prophecies, making it a central point in the narrative.

Bran the Builder

Explanation: Some fans theorize that Bran Stark, as the Three-Eyed Raven, has time-traveled and is the legendary figure Bran the Builder who constructed the Wall and Winterfell.

Popularity: This theory connects key historical elements of Westeros with Bran’s abilities, sparking debates about time and destiny.

The Night King’s Origin

Explanation: Theories abound regarding the Night King’s origins, with some suggesting he could be a Stark or a figure related to the First Men.

Popularity: The ambiguity around the Night King’s backstory has led to much speculation, although the show did not delve deeply into his origins.

Controversial or Less Popular Theories

Sansa as the True Villain

Explanation: Some fans theorize that Sansa Stark will ultimately become the main antagonist, manipulating events for her gain.

Skepticism: This theory is often dismissed as it contradicts her character development and the themes of resilience and growth.

Cleganebowl: The Mountain vs. The Hound

Explanation: This theory posits a final showdown between Sandor Clegane (The Hound) and Gregor Clegane (The Mountain).

Skepticism: While it gained traction, some critics argue it feels too fan-service-y and lacks depth in the overall narrative.

Tyrion is a Targaryen

Explanation: This theory suggests that Tyrion Lannister is actually the son of Aerys II Targaryen, making him a Targaryen by blood.

Skepticism: While it has some textual support, many fans find it less convincing and feel it complicates Tyrion’s character arc unnecessarily.

Conclusion

Theories about ASOIAF and GoT are a significant part of the fan experience, fostering discussion and speculation. Some theories have gained widespread acceptance and add depth to the narrative, while others remain divisive and are often debated among fans. The rich world created by George R.R. Martin allows for diverse interpretations, keeping the community engaged as they await the completion of the book series.