Examining Potential Plot Holes and Mistakes in The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien, a monumental work of literature, has been examined and dissected for its intricacies and nuances, yet it is not without its share of potential plot holes and inconsistencies. From the Eagles’ role to Gandalf’s knowledge and the one Ring's influence, this article delves into these areas to explore the depth and complexity of Tolkien’s world.

The Eagles Role

One of the most discussed aspects of The Lord of the Rings is the Eagles’ role, particularly why the Fellowship did not use the Eagles to fly to Mount Doom. The Eagles, powerful beings of great renown, are absent during crucial moments. This raises questions about their role in the narrative. Why would the authors, whether by design or omission, choose to have these beings present yet fail to utilize their power to aid the protagonists?

Gandalf’s Knowledge

Gandalf, the wizard, seems to have extensive knowledge about Sauron and his plans. He often makes decisions that appear inconsistent with what one might expect, such as allowing Frodo to take the One Ring to Mount Doom alone. This inconsistency can lead to questions about the nature of his knowledge and the reasons behind his decisions.

The Timing of Events

The timeline of events, particularly in The Return of the King, is subject to careful scrutiny. The sudden appearance of the Army of the Dead at the Battle of Pelennor Fields raises questions about their prior existence and why they chose to aid Aragorn at that moment. This creates a gap in the timeline that fans and critics alike wonder about.

The One Ring’s Influence

The One Ring has a corrupting influence that varies among characters. For example, Gollum is deeply affected, but figures like Aragorn and Galadriel show remarkable resistance. This inconsistency can lead to questions about the nature of the Ring’s power and its effect on different individuals.

Faramir’s Characterization

In the books, Faramir is portrayed as a noble character who resists the Ring's temptation. However, in the film adaptation, his character is slightly altered to initially seek the Ring for Gondor. This contrast can be seen as inconsistent with his book portrayal, leading to some fan disappointment.

Gimli and Legolas’ Competition

The ongoing competition between Gimli and Legolas regarding kills in battle, while adding comic relief, seems somewhat trivial given the gravity of their situation. This can be seen as an incongruity that some readers or viewers might find puzzling.

Exemplified Plot Holes

One of the best-known alleged plot holes is why the Eagles carried Frodo and Sam back from Mount Doom but did not help them fly the One Ring there or at other critical points, like the crossing of the Misty Mountains. This raises questions about the choice and execution of the story.

Gandalf’s Gunpowder Factory

Another interesting inconsistency is Gandalf’s gunpowder factory. Early in the first chapter, Bilbo is planning for his 111th birthday bash and ordered fireworks from Gandalf. However, elsewhere, we are given to believe that Gandalf is a wandering wizard, and only Saruman has a permanent abode. How did Bilbo contact Gandalf, and where did Gandalf make the fireworks? Fireworks are made from black powder, which requires saltpeter, a hard-to-come-by ingredient. Where did Gandalf obtain it, along with sulfur and charcoal? These questions highlight the intricate world-building challenges and potential inconsistencies within Tolkien's creation.

While these points are subject to scrutiny, many fans appreciate the depth and complexity of Tolkien's world. These inconsistencies, often viewed as minor, do not overshadow the overall narrative and themes of the story.