Erle Stanley Gardner: A Legacy of Writing and Its Future Legacy

Introduction to Erle Stanley Gardner

Erle Stanley Gardner is a name that may be slightly forgotten in the annals of the modern literary world. His prolific output and dedication to the legal thriller genre have left an indelible mark on the literary landscape, especially within the realm of the mystery and detective novel. Ralph Waldo Emerson once wrote, 'A book is like a garden carried somewhere in your pocket—fruitful, blooming always.' Despite Gardner's often criticized approach to his craft, his work has not only serialized itself but also suffused the popular culture with its characters and tropes.

Erle Stanley Gardner's Approach to Writing

While Gardner’s method was described as mechanistic and more of a ‘churning out stories’ approach rather than a creative pursuit, it was a testament to his consistent output. Gardner’s relentless passion for writing was such that he considered even his vacations as an opportunity for literary productivity. This embrace of storytelling, wherever he found himself, allowed him to produce an extensive corpus of work, with over 30 Perry Mason novels alone. In a time when such dedication was prevalent, it might be considered naive now, but it is a remarkable testament to the importance of routine and discipline in creative endeavors.

Legacy and Impact of Gardner's Writing

Erle Stanley Gardner’s impact is significant, particularly in the genre of legal thrillers. His most famous creation, the lawyer Perry Mason, became an archetype for many subsequent mystery and detective storylines. Gardner’s ability to weave complex legal situations and human drama into his narratives helped solidify the legal thriller as a recognized and respected subgenre. The Perry Mason series, with over 80 novels, introduced readers to a world of legal intrigue and human empowerment.

Critical Reception of Gardner's Work

While in earlier times, this level of output was valued and respected, the modern literary world often scrutinizes such prolific writers in a more critical light. Critics and readers may find Aldous Huxley’s description apropos: “A mind like his, of highly organized powers, conceived in itself a series of experiments in charming literary executions.” Gardner was indeed a writer who executed stories with a consistent formula, often called a "writing machine." His novels followed a well-established formula, which many have critiqued for a lack of originality or creativity. However, there is a magic in consistency and reliability that resonates with many readers.

Is Erle Stanley Gardner Still Read?

Today, the question of whether Gardner's work is still read and for what reason becomes intriguing. Gardner’s legacy in the literary world might not be as celebrated as it once was, but there is still an audience that appreciates his stories. The enduring popularity of Perry Mason on television and his frequent appearances in popular culture have kept his name relevant. This shows that while readers may critique Gardner's methods, his stories and characters still manage to connect with a significant number of people.

Conclusion: The Continuing Relevance of Erle Stanley Gardner’s Work

Erle Stanley Gardner’s legacy is complex and multifaceted. While his approach to writing might not align with modern literary standards, his contributions to the genre of legal thrillers and his influence on the narrative structure of detective stories cannot be overlooked. His ability to craft compelling stories and his dedication to his craft have left a lasting impact on the literary and popular cultures of his time and beyond. Whether one admires his output or criticizes it, Erle Stanley Gardner’s work continues to be a subject of discussion and reflection.

Keyword: Erle Stanley Gardner, legal thriller, Perry Mason