Why Edward Cullen is Considered the Worst Boyfriend in Twilight

Twilight, the popular young adult series by Stephenie Meyer, has enthralled fans with its romantic and sometimes controversial storylines. One character who often raises eyebrows is Edward Cullen, the alpha male of the Cullen family. Many readers and critics argue that Edward makes the worst boyfriend ever due to his stalkerish behavior, abusive traits, and overall odd character traits. This article delves into why Edward Cullen is considered the epitome of a bad boyfriend in the Twilight universe.

Stalkerish Behavior

One of the most criticized aspects of Edward Cullen's behavior is his stalkerish tendencies. From the very first meeting with Bella Swan, Edward's obsession becomes clear. He follows Bella, shows up at unexpected moments, and overall exhibits behavior that is overly intrusive and unsettling.

Examples of Stalking Behavior

Following Bella to school and even to a hospital Predicting where Bella will be at specific times Leaving flowers and gifts at her doorstep

These actions, while often romanticized in media, are actually quite terrifying. Stalking involves a pattern of persistent and unwanted attention, which can be extremely harmful to the person being followed. In a real-world context, this behavior would be classified as a form of harassment and would be illegal.

Emotional and Physical Abuse

Edward's relationship with Bella is also marred by his tendency to control and manipulate her. He is known to make decisions for Bella, often without her consent, and at times, his controlling behavior can be described as abusive. This is evident in his insistence that Bella drink blood to survive, despite Bella being vegan and not wanting to compromise her values for him.

Abusive Trait Examples

Forcing Bella to drink blood against her will Refusing to let Bella leave Forks or move away Exhibiting jealousy and possessiveness over Bella's other relationships

These actions are indicative of an emotionally and psychologically abusive relationship, where the partner in question (Edward) is using manipulative tactics to maintain control over Bella.

Odd Character Traits

Edward's odd character traits include his refusal to explore the world outside his vampire family. Instead of seeking new experiences, he chooses to remain stagnant, living a life that is essentially unchanged for centuries. This decision is deeply unsettling, as it removes any element of growth or adventure from his life, making him a static and uninteresting character.

Implications of Edward's Stagnation

Lack of personal growth Limited emotional depth Repetitive and unchanging lifestyle

Furthermore, Edward's study at an institutionalized school for 100 years rather than exploring the world or engaging in other activities suggests a life devoid of excitement and purpose. This aspect of his character is often overlooked in discussions about his personality but is a significant factor in why many readers and critics view him as a bad boyfriend.

Why Edward Cullen Continues to Be a Controversial Choice for a Romantic Lead

Despite being a central figure in the Twilight saga, Edward Cullen's character is deeply flawed. His stalkerish behavior, abusive traits, and odd character traits have made him a polarizing character in the young adult fiction world. Many readers find it hard to romanticize Edward's controlling and manipulative behavior, especially when it involves Bella, who is portrayed as a more dynamic and relatable character.

The criticism of Edward Cullen often leads to discussions about abusive relationships in fiction and the importance of portraying healthy and respectful relationships in literature for young readers. While some fans may still root for Edward and Bella's relationship, the majority of critics and readers find his character to be a prime example of the worst kind of boyfriend.

Conclusion

Edward Cullen's portrayal in Twilight as a stalker, abuser, and a character with no desire for personal growth is a significant reason why many view him as the worst boyfriend ever. His behavior and character traits raise important questions about the depiction of relationships in young adult fiction and the importance of portraying healthy, respectful, and dynamic relationships.