Introduction

The recent decision by Walt Disney World to remove the Brer Rabbit attraction from Magic Kingdom has sparked considerable debate. Many argue that the dismantling of this beloved part of the park is a waste, while others support the move for its alignment with contemporary values. This article delves into the implications of this change and explores potential alternatives to the current approach.

The Controversy

The removal of the Brer Rabbit attraction is often seen as a wasted effort and expenditure. Critics argue that the story does not carry racist undertones and should not be removed. The argument is further strengthened by the fact that the majority of visitors have not and do not perceive the ride as problematic. This includes the idea of banning the book 'Black Sambo,' which is often compared to the Uncle Remus stories in terms of historical context.

My Opinion on the Decision

In my view, the decision to remove the Brer Rabbit stories from Splash Mountain is unfortunate and represents a missed opportunity. While it is true that these stories originated in the long-disavowed film 'Song of the South,' the stories themselves can be celebrated as interesting morality tales. Joel Chandler Harris published the first of seven books of Uncle Remus stories in 1881, which aimed to represent the struggle in the Southern United States, particularly on plantations. The Uncle Remus tales feature Brer Rabbit, Brer Bear, and Brer Fox, who are not depicted in a stereotypical light. Instead, they are part of a rich folklore tradition that can be celebrated and appreciated.

Alternative Approach: A Celebration of Black Folklore

Instead of dismantling the current story, Disney should repurpose Splash Mountain as a celebration of black folklore. This approach would highlight the stories as interesting morality tales that resonate with a broader audience. By explaining the historical context of the stories and how they were passed down among black plantation communities, Disney could create a more inclusive narrative. The stories of Brer Rabbit, Brer Bear, and Brer Fox are not inherently racist but rather examples of cleverness and wit, which are universal themes.

Rationale for Updating the Ride

There are multiple reasons to update the ride. Firstly, the majority of park visitors have never seen the movie 'Song of the South' or its characters, and thus the current story lacks resonance. Secondly, it would be pragmatically beneficial to update the ride to reflect themes that are more relatable to a wider audience. The current storyline, while enjoyable, may be seen as tone-deaf and out of touch.

Conclusion

The removal of Brer Rabbit from Splash Mountain represents a missed opportunity to celebrate and educate visitors about black folklore. By reimagining the ride as a celebration of these stories, Disney could create a more engaging and inclusive experience. The potential for this approach extends beyond just the ride, offering a platform for storytelling and cultural appreciation that aligns with modern sensibilities.