Did Boromir Know About Aragorn’s Ancestry in Rivendell?

Many readers of The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien are curious about the relationship between the characters, particularly regarding the knowledge of Boromir and Aragorn's connection to Isildur. This article delves into this fascinating topic, exploring what Boromir knew about Aragorn and his ancestry before meeting him in Rivendell.

The Historical Context

The rulers of Gondor, the Stewards, held a mysterious lineage back to the renowned Isildur, the son of Elendil and the one who famously claimed the One Ring for himself. However, there is no evidence suggesting that Boromir, a direct descendant of the ruling Stewards, knew about this during their journey from Gondor to Rivendell. The Stewards never claimed the throne because their lineage was not legitimate, as they were not descendants of the Kings.

Meeting in Rivendell and the Initial Encounters

When Boromir and Aragorn first meet in Rivendell, they do not know each other. Boromir arrives at Rivendell having received a dream that involves a riddle related to Frodo and the breaking of a sword. However, Aragorn, being a ranger of the north, is not well-known in Gondor, let alone his true heritage.

The Revelation at The Council of Elrond

The pivotal moment in this series of events occurs during the Council of Elrond. In this vital chapter, it is revealed to Boromir that Aragorn is indeed a descendant of Isildur. This revelation comes as a surprise to Boromir, who had no prior knowledge of Aragorn's heritage. The Council also discloses the true nature of Aragorn's lineage, including his ties to both Isildur and Anarion, and his rightful claim to the throne of Gondor.

Boromir's Skepticism and Prejudices

Boromir, a proud Gondorian of the Stewardship of the line of Hurin, has been fighting Mordor his entire life. He sees himself as a true man of Gondor and is skeptical of Aragorn's identity as a direct descendant of Isildur. Boromir believes that any true claimant to the throne should be actively fighting in Gondor rather than being a ranger in the north. This skepticism leads to frequent clashes between Boromir and Aragorn during their journey together, as Aragorn must constantly correct Boromir’s misconceptions and assumptions.

A Divergence of Perspectives

Their interactions are marked by a widening gap in their understanding and perspectives. For Boromir, his role as a Steward and his experience in the wars against Mordor shape his view of leadership and duty. Aragorn, on the other hand, carries with him the legacy of his ancestors and the weight of potential responsibility. Their journey through Middle-earth highlights the different paths they have taken and their contrasting visions for the future of Gondor.

Conclusion

From the outset, it is clear that Boromir did not know about Aragorn's true identity and lineage in Rivendell. The revelation at The Council of Elrond marks a turning point in their relationship and in the broader narrative of The Lord of the Rings. The journey that follows showcases the tensions and eventual understanding that develops between two very different characters, bound by the fate of Middle-earth and the power of the One Ring.

Understanding these dynamics not only enriches our reading of The Lord of the Rings but also offers valuable insights into themes of legacy, identity, and the complexities of leadership in a time of crisis.