Choosing the Right Version of Apocalypse Now: Original or Redux

Have you ever found yourself wondering which version of Apocalypse Now to watch if you've never seen it before? The decision between the original 1979 theatrical release and the 2001 redux version can significantly impact your viewing experience, particularly when it comes to pacing, atmosphere, and the richness of character development.

The Original 1979 Theatrical Release

The original 1979 theatrical release of Apocalypse Now is the best version to start with if you're looking for an immersive and intense movie-watching experience. This version, clocking in at around 147 minutes, is generally considered more accessible and impactful. It captures the film's dense atmosphere and profound themes effectively, making it a solid choice for those new to this iconic war film.

Its runtime and strong storytelling make it a classic choice, ideal for those who value a cohesive narrative and a compelling depiction of the Vietnam War. If you prefer the original's pacing and thematic intensity, it's worth sticking with the theatrical release for your first viewing.

The 2001 Redux Version

For those who appreciate a more expansive narrative, the Apocalypse Now Redux version, which was released in 2001, may be the better choice. This extended cut adds approximately 49 minutes of additional footage, providing more context and character development. If you're intrigued by the film's deeper layers and want to experience a more comprehensive story, this version is a must-watch.

While the extended scenes in Redux can offer a richer understanding of the characters, some viewers find that they detract from the original's intense pacing and atmosphere. Therefore, it's important to approach this version with an open mind and be prepared for a longer runtime. If you enjoy exploring the nuances of a film's narrative and are willing to tolerate a slightly less focused experience, the Redux version is a worth seeing.

My Personal Recommendation

After careful consideration, I prefer the original 1979 theatrical release. In my opinion, the Redux version's "plantation scene" is too long and overly literal, significantly detracting from the movie's momentum. However, the scene where Kurtz lets Willard out of his cell and reads the New York Times to him, as exclusive to the Redux, is priceless. Despite being a bit too literal with Kurtz's contempt for political spin from home, this scene is short and sweet, an unexpected gem that fell largely by the wayside in the original cut.

Additional Thoughts on the Redux Version

While the Redux version is interesting if you're keen on seeing director Francis Ford Coppola's vision, it's important to note that the pacing is significantly impacted. The extensive editing and added scenes, while offering a deeper insight into the film, might not align with the original's flow. As a result, unless you specifically want to explore Decorating Director's Chair-style video essays, it's often better to watch the original first and then explore the Redux if you have the time and interest.

If you can find a copy of the original release, start with that. Then, if you have three extra hours in your schedule, check out the director's cuts. Lastly, delve into the documentary about the troubled production of Apocalypse Now. This will not only give you a well-rounded view of the film's creation but also a deeper understanding of the challenges Coppola faced during its production.

As we reflect on the rich legacy of Apocalypse Now, it's clear that both versions offer unique insights and experiences. Whether you start with the original or explore the Redux, you'll undoubtedly find a powerful film that resonates with the complexities of the human experience.