Introduction

In the Legends of Middle-earth, named by J.R.R. Tolkien, the concept of the fairest being, whether an elf, a half-elf, or potentially an Ainur, holds a significant place. This article explores the fairness of elven figures, particularly delving into the tales of Dior Eluchíl, Luthien Tinuviel, and Arwen. We will discuss how these characters, though often overshadowed by Arwen's beauty in literature, possess their unique splendor. So, let's embark on this journey to uncover the truth behind the prettiest figures among Tolkien's creations.

The Fairest of All Elves: Dior Eluchíl

Dior Eluchíl is not just another elf, but a perfect amalgamation of various races: one who descends from the Edain (Men), the Eldar (Elves), and even stands on the threshold by virtue of his association with Ainur (spirits, including angelic beings). This unique identity rightfully claims him as the fairest of all the children of the world of threefold race.

A section of the Morgan(attribute missing)ev WEnding, mentions Dior:

Then Dior arose and about his neck he clasped the Nauglamír, and now he appeared as the fairest of all the children of the world of threefold race: of the Edain and of the Eldar and of the Maiar of the Blessed Realm.

While the shine and magic of the Nauglamír (a necklace) play a part in Dior's radiance, it is the essences of his ancestors and the blended purity of his being that truly define his unparalleled beauty.

The Beauty of Luthien Tinuviel

Luthien Tinuviel, one of the most famous elven maidens in Tolkien's work, is often regarded as the fairest of the Elves. Her beauty captivated the Valar and Ainur, and she is known to have been hired by Melian, the Maia, to serve as a visage in Middle-earth. Luthien's beauty was legendary, second only perhaps to the beauty of Melian herself.

Tolkien himself once described Luthien as the most beautiful woman in Middle-earth:

Tolkien described the most beautiful woman to ever walk in Middle-earth as being Melian, though she was no elf; she had an elf for a daughter, as she married Elu Thingol. Luthien was the most fair of the elves, though Arwen was said to resemble her greatly. The story of Beren and Lúthien was inspired greatly by the romance of the author and his wife, Edith Bratt.

Arwen, the Equal of Luthien Tinuviel

Arwen, daughter of Elrond, was perceived to have resembling Luthien and was often considered to be her equal, or nearly so, in beauty. Aranel, the previous and original name of Arwen, was just as stunning. Despite Arwen's legendary beauty, she emerges in relative silence in comparison to the Myrmidons she embodies from her lineage.

It is a well-documented fact that Gimli the Dwarf considered Galadriel more beautiful than Arwen. This judgment is not without its own context; given that Galadriel soothed Gimli's lack of affection between elves and dwarves and bestowed upon him a gift, his admiration for her beauty is understandable. However, Galadriel's exquisite hair, thought to be a divine inspiration for the creation of the Silmarils, may further validate her position as a rival to Arwen in the realm of beauty.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

The debate over which of these figures is the fairest is both poignant and complex. Each of these beings—Dior Eluchíl, Luthien Tinuviel, and Arwen—possesses a distinct radiance that distinguishes them. Dior's unique heritage, Luthien's enduring allure, and Arwen's resonant beauty all bear testament to the varied forms of beauty found within Tolkien's expansive universe. So, next time you search for the fairest among Tolkien's characters, remember the profound beauty that lies not only in their physical appearance but in the stories and legacies they embody.

Keywords: Elves, Fairest of All, Tolkien's Beings