Altered Thrones: A Lannister Family Changed Scenario with the Return of Tywin

In the world of A Song of Ice and Fire and its adaptations, the return of Tywin Lannister as Hand of the King would lead to a series of significant changes in the narrative. This hypothetical scenario explores what would happen if Tywin returned to power after Ned Stark dies and Jon Arryn is no longer alive. Specifically, Cersei Lannister may not be able to have Robert Baratheon killed, and there would be considerable shifts in the power dynamics of the Seven Kingdoms.

Imagining a New Hand of the King

If Tywin Lannister were to return as Hand of the King, the narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire would unquestionably diverge from its original path. Firstly, it is unlikely that Cersei would attempt to have Robert killed to secure her position. With her father, Tywin, in charge, there is no need to rush Joffrey to the throne. Joffrey has a clear and powerful example to follow, potentially mitigating some of his worst impulses. As Bronn once observed in Game of Thrones, 'There is no cure for being a cunt,' but with Tywin’s prudent guidance, the realm might hope for some measure of stability.

Rearrangement of the Small Council

With Tywin as the new Hand of the King, certain key positions in the small council would need to be reevaluated. Littlefinger’s days would be numbered. Tywin would prefer a man of sense and trustworthiness for the role of Master of Coin, with Tyrion Lannister being a strong candidate. This move towards a more traditional and reliable form of governance would signal a shift away from the cunning and manipulative nature that Varys represents. With no civil war looming, it would be easier for Tywin to ensure that his own people held key positions of power, reinforcing Lannister dominance.

The Westerlands Decisive Action

The remaining Targaryens are considered dead, and Tywin would indeed, and perhaps even more decisively, encourage Robert to complete their annihilation. Any Targaryen uprisings would face the sharp end of the Lannister sword. This would ensure that no chances for rebellion remain, further solidifying Tywin’s and Robert’s control over the realm.

Securing the Kingdoms

With Tywin’s long-term vision, the unification of the Kingdoms to the Crown is a top priority. Given his pragmatic approach, Joffrey is not married to Sansa Stark. The North, while fiercely loyal, needs more than mere marriage alliances to secure it. Dorne, the Vale, and Highgarden present potential challenges, but Highgarden is considered the most crucial. Joffrey’s marriage to Margery Tyrell would be a sensible choice, securing the powerful House Tyrell’s loyalty.

To draw the Vale into the fold, Tywin would arrange for a betrothal between Myrcella Lannister and Robin Arryn. Robb Stark, given his disobedient and powerful nature, would be targeted through a match with either a Lannister or a Martell, ensuring he is brought to heel. This series of marriages would secure the Lannisters’ grip on the realm, with Tommen’s potential matches serving to solidify the Lannister influence over the North and Riverlands.

The Long-Term Legacy of Tywin Lannister

The return of Tywin Lannister as Hand of the King would not only secure the Lannisters’ power for generations but would also sow the seeds for future conflicts. Once Tywin and Robert are gone, Joffrey and his family would be left in a precarious position. The brooding war hero, Bran Stark, would eventually be executed for his incestuous relationship with his sister, and the true heir, Jaime Lannister, would not be recognized.

This hypothetical narrative underscores the intricate balance of power, the importance of succession, and the lasting impact of key decisions made by influential characters. In a world where A Song of Ice and Fire thrives, the true test of a ruler lies not just in their ability to seize power but in their capacity to maintain and consolidate it for the long term.

Keywords: A Song of Ice and Fire, Tyrion Lannister, Varys, Cersei Lannister

Related Keywords: Joffrey Baratheon, Tywin Lannister, Robert Baratheon, Dorne, Westerlands, Tyrells, Targaryens