Adults and Young Adult Literature: Should Reading YA Books Be Embarrassing?

How often do we face the question: should adults feel embarrassed for enjoying Young Adult (YA) books? This age-old debate is often fueled by personal preferences, societal norms, and cultural judgments. In this article, we delve into this discussion, exploring various perspectives and understanding the importance of reading diversification.

Why We Shouldn’t Be Embarrassed

It is unreasonable to assume that adults should feel ashamed for enjoying YA books. Social norms can sometimes dictate that certain genres are reserved for younger readers, which is not necessarily true. Books, whether they are for young adults or adults, are meant to educate, inspire, and entertain. Reading YA books can be a legitimate choice based on personal interest and enjoyment.

Some argue that the repetitive themes and characters in many YA books can be mundane. However, this criticism often overlooks the creative interpretations and depth that can be found in well-written novels. Similarly, it is important to recognize that book preference is a personal choice and should not be socially stigmatized.

Take, for instance, the quote by C.S. Lewis, which reminds us that we should not let societal pressures dictate our choices. Instead, we should enjoy what entertains us. Reading YA books can be a source of joy and can even provide valuable insights into the younger generation's viewpoint and struggles.

Is Society Judging YA Books?

Some argue that society has a contemptuous attitude towards movies, music, TV shows, and books targeted at teens and children. It is true that there is often an emphasis on more sophisticated and mature content for entertainment. However, a diverse range of genres, including YA, can cater to a wide audience and offer a different perspective.

PG-13 films, for example, are designed to appeal to all ages, making them accessible to a broad audience. While some may lament the lack of G-rated movies, this often reflects the commercial appeal of more mature content. The suggestions to show a wider range of films (such as NC-17) highlight the limited options for certain age groups, which is a valid concern.

In the same vein, YA literature can also provide a unique perspective. Unlike adult literature, which often excludes certain themes, YA books can explore sensitive topics like death, rape, drugs, and suicide. By reading such books, adults can gain a deeper understanding of the world from a younger person's perspective, which can be both enlightening and beneficial.

Parents and Children’s Literature

Parents often have a responsibility to read the books their children enjoy to understand the content and its impact. For instance, two books I read last year were written from the perspectives of different characters, including a parent and a child. Both were well-written and tackled some very real issues.

Reading from these perspectives can be eye-opening and can help parents engage in meaningful discussions with their children. It is a form of communication and understanding that can lead to a better relationship and a more informed parenting style.

Conclusion

In conclusion, adults should not feel embarrassed for enjoying Young Adult books. The decision to read a particular genre should be based on individual interest and enjoyment rather than societal expectations. YA literature, in particular, can provide valuable insights and diverse perspectives that can enrich our understanding of the world and our empathy towards younger generations.